prepared, and how alterations were made at the direction of Mrs. Bellows. He identified pages where Rose's destination changed after the fact and where a purported guardian's signature had been copied onto a second sheet. His answers were precise, although his voice shook when he admitted he knew the changes were improper.
Shaw's attorney questioned him sharply about the time that had passed. Could he truly remember who stood in an office thirty years before? Did he have a personal dispute with Shaw? Had anyone promised him payment to travel west? Hodge answered that he remembered some events poorly and therefore relied on dated notes rather than claiming perfect recollection. He had been given money for transportation and lodging by the legal team, not a reward for testimony. When asked why he had not reported the false entries sooner, he looked at the judge. "I was afraid," he said. "And I found it convenient to call fear prudence for a very long time."
Rose heard a murmur pass through the room. The admission did not make Hodge noble. It made him credible in a way a polished defense might not have. Caroline then produced records from the Kansas farm showing Rose working there during the period when the disputed amendment had supposedly been signed by her in another county. The clerk certified the dates and identified a wage entry under her married name. Shaw's lawyer suggested travel was possible, but presented no evidence that Rose had left the farm during that time. The magistrate asked him whether he disputed the dates themselves. After a pause, the lawyer said he did not.
When Rose was called, she stood with her hands clasped until Caroline gently told her she could hold the witness rail. She gave her birth name as she remembered it, described the coat label, the years at St. Agnes, and the separation from Nell. She told the court how she learned of the ranch through her friend's letter, how she reached Bitter Creek with eleven dollars, and how the deed appeared inside the drawer after Molly recognized the pie crust. The mention of the child drew attention, but Rose resisted turning it into a dramatic account. Molly's words mattered to the family; the legal case rested on documents, identities, and corroboration.
Shaw's attorney asked whether Rose had known Nell was convicted of theft when she first came to the ranch. She said no. Had she concealed the deed after finding it? She said she had spent one night reading it and brought it to Caleb the same evening. Had she intended to dispossess him? She answered that she had consulted a lawyer precisely because she did not know what rights the paper established. The attorney asked whether she hoped to marry Caleb and thereby gain his ranch regardless of the deed. Rose felt her face warm, but Caroline rose to object before she replied. The magistrate sustained the objection because speculation about a private relationship did not answer the authenticity question.