A Rancher's Daughter Hadn't Spoken in 11 Months — Then She Tasted a Poor Widow's Apple Pie

Chapter 21

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"Why do you need the cruel parts?" Rose asked after a while. Caroline put down her pen. "Because Shaw will argue those placements were kindly arrangements. A court may be tempted to accept that if the papers appear neat. The lived facts can help show what those papers disguised." Rose considered that answer. She did not wish to spend the remainder of her life being known as a mistreated orphan, but she could bear speaking of it if the account might prevent another family from mistaking exploitation for benevolence.

Molly listened outside the kitchen doorway until Abigail found her. The child had become watchful whenever strangers visited, and she associated serious voices with adults going away. Abigail led her to the porch and brought out a basket of mending. "I know you want to hear what they're saying," she told her niece. "But grown people sometimes put their troubles on a table so they can sort them. It doesn't mean those troubles belong to you." Molly looked toward the lawyer's black hat. "Are they taking Rose?" Abigail shook her head. "No one is taking her today. She chooses where to go. That's an important difference."

Molly looked down. "Mama didn't choose to go." Abigail's needle stopped. She had avoided speaking of death with the child unless absolutely necessary, because every explanation seemed to reopen the wound. Now she recognized that silence had become another kind of frightening mystery. "No," she said. "Your mama became sick, and all of us tried to help her stay. We could not. But Rose isn't sick, and a court paper doesn't make her disappear. We are going to tell you when anything important changes."

That night Molly asked Rose whether people could have two mothers. The question caught Rose as she folded a clean sheet at the bedside. She sat on the mattress rather than answering from above the child. "Some children do," she said. "Some have a mother who gives birth to them and another grown woman who helps raise them. Some have aunts, grandmothers, or friends who love them very much. But no one can replace your mama, and I don't want to pretend that I can." Molly considered this. "I want you here," she whispered. Rose took her hand. "I want to be here, too, as long as the grown-up things can be made fair."

Caleb heard the conversation from the hall and went outside with a tightness in his chest. He wanted his daughter to heal, yet the speed with which Molly reached toward Rose frightened him. If Rose left once the property question was settled, would Molly lose another person she had allowed herself to trust? And if Rose stayed, would her presence slowly erase the small habits by which the house remembered Ellen? He was ashamed of thinking either thought. He knew love was not measured by the absence of other affection, but grief often made arithmetic of the heart where arithmetic did not belong.

News in the same category

A Rancher's Daughter Hadn't Spoken in 11 Months — Then She Tasted a Poor Widow's Apple Pie

50 Part