A Rancher's Daughter Hadn't Spoken in 11 Months — Then She Tasted a Poor Widow's Apple Pie

Chapter 11

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"No," Rose said. "Sometimes love makes people afraid to risk it. That doesn't make the silence right." Caleb looked down and turned the cup slowly between his palms. They talked until the lamp grew dim, not reaching agreement but arriving at something more useful: neither would make a decision about the deed without speaking to a lawyer or county recorder, and neither would frighten Molly with an argument about ownership.

The next morning Caleb spread a sheet of figures beside the document and began adding expenses. Rose saw the records for a well dug nine years before, a barn rebuilt after a winter storm, and miles of fence wire bought on credit. He had worked the land since before the claimed transfer, and he had improved it with labor that could not simply be assigned a price. "If the deed holds," he said, "I'll pay fair rent for whatever years the law says I owe. Or I'll take Molly and Abigail to my brother's place until we settle. I won't ask you to give away what Ellen kept for you."

Rose looked at the figures and felt a weight settle over her. Men had told her what she owed since childhood. Nobody had offered to surrender a roof simply because a paper showed it belonged to someone else. "You'd leave?" she asked. "I don't want to," Caleb replied. "But wanting is a poor argument against someone's rights." Rose put the pencil aside. "I haven't said the ranch is mine. I've said we need to find out. And until we do, no one leaves."

Molly stood in the kitchen doorway holding the tintype. She pointed to Rose and then to the picture. "That's you," she whispered. "Mama said you were coming." Rose glanced at Caleb, whose face changed at the reference. Molly considered the two adults and added, "Mama cut the pie in half. One side was for the girl who wasn't here." Abigail made a small sound near the stove. The words were new, but the memory they contained had belonged to Molly for months, waiting behind the silence.

"She told you that?" Caleb asked. Molly nodded. "Sometimes she'd leave a piece by the window. For Rose." Caleb went very still. He had seen Ellen set aside pie before and assumed she wanted it for a neighbor or for later. The small ceremony now made sense. Rose drew Molly against her and finally allowed herself to cry for the friend who had spent years setting a place at a table Rose did not know existed.

That afternoon the first rider appeared on the ridge. Abigail saw him while hanging blankets and called Caleb out before he reached the gate. The man rode a gray gelding, wore a black coat dusty at the hem, and sat in his saddle with the patience of someone accustomed to people coming to him. His whiskers were silver and neatly kept; his gloves were clean despite the rough road. He lifted a hand politely, then looked past Caleb at the house as if he had already decided its dimensions.

"Mr. Whitcomb," he said. "I've heard you have a visitor who may be keeping something of mine."

News in the same category

A Rancher's Daughter Hadn't Spoken in 11 Months — Then She Tasted a Poor Widow's Apple Pie

50 Part