Shaw's face remained composed. "A very serious accusation. Shall we add defamation to the matter?"
"You can add what you like," Rose answered. "It will not change the entries." She unwrapped the book enough for the deputy to see the first page, then opened to the names indexed beside Judge Vale's signature. Owen bent closer. His mother had grown up in a charitable home near St. Louis, and the column headed placement gave him a fear he could not yet put into words. He read three pages, then stopped with one finger pressed against the name of a girl who had the same surname as his mother's sister.
"Where did you get this?" he asked. Rose explained Nell's imprisonment, the false-bottomed pie tin, and the letter discovered that morning. She did not pretend the ledger itself was a court ruling. She offered to make a sworn statement and asked that the document be preserved, with copies kept outside Judge Vale's influence. Owen looked at Shaw, whose mild smile had finally disappeared. "This belongs in the sheriff's evidence locker," the deputy said. "And there will have to be witnesses to each step."
"You are exceeding your authority," Shaw replied. His hand moved toward the inside of his coat, then stopped when Caleb stepped down from the porch and Abigail appeared behind the screen with the old shotgun. No one pointed a weapon. Nobody had to. The space around the gate had changed from one man's performance to a scene with several witnesses, none willing to accept his word as law. Shaw considered the deputy and the documents, then removed his hand empty. "I have counsel," he said. "You will hear from him."
Owen asked Shaw to dismount and accompany him to Sweetwater for questioning about the threatened seizure and the documents. Shaw argued, then complied when the deputy said he could refuse an informal interview but could not take possession of the ledger or the deed at the ranch. Caleb and Rose agreed to travel with the deputy to make statements rather than surrender the originals without receipts and independent copies. They did not mistake this step for an arrest or an end to the danger. Shaw might still have allies in town, and they had no way to know what the evidence would prove after professional review.
Before the men left, Molly came onto the porch in bare feet. She carried the old pie pan, holding it with both hands as though it were a treasure. "That's my mama's," she said, pointing toward the wrapped book. "You don't get any of it." Shaw turned toward her, and for an instant Rose saw an emotion close to anger flicker across his face. Caleb moved to stand beside his daughter, but Molly did not hide. She stood in the light of the doorway with Abigail behind her and Rose close enough to take her hand.