A Rancher's Daughter Hadn't Spoken in 11 Months — Then She Tasted a Poor Widow's Apple Pie

Chapter 30

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

A week later Daniel Hodge arrived from St. Louis with one small trunk and a tired face. He was older than Rose remembered and moved stiffly, but his eyes sharpened when he saw her name written in Caroline's records. He said he had worked at St. Agnes for twelve years, first as a junior clerk, later in charge of accounts. He had seen Mrs. Bellows meet Shaw behind closed doors and watched the home's expenses paid partly by placement fees. He claimed he suspected wrongdoing long before he acted. Caroline asked him not to summarize his feelings but to identify the records he could authenticate.

Hodge produced a bound notebook of alterations. Each entry noted the original date, the correction demanded, and the person who ordered it. One page recorded Rosalind Pierce's departure with a destination in Missouri; another, written weeks later, replaced that destination with a Kansas farm and inserted a purported guardian's approval. The signature was copied by someone who did not understand the original hand. Hodge said he had kept the notebook to protect himself if auditors ever asked why dates changed. "I told myself it was professional caution," he admitted. "I was really afraid of losing my wages."

Rose listened with her hands folded so tightly her knuckles hurt. When he finished, she asked what he remembered of the day she left. Hodge said he remembered two girls beneath the eaves, the smaller crying because the other was being taken away. "I thought you were sisters," he said. "Mrs. Bellows told me that was foolish sentiment and that attachments made children unmanageable." Rose saw Nell again with the blue ribbon between her fingers. "We were sisters," she replied. "Not because anybody signed a paper. Because she was the one who stayed when I was afraid."

Hodge bowed his head. "I should have done something."

"Yes," Rose said. She did not soften the word. The man looked up and accepted it. She added, "You are doing something now. That matters. It doesn't change what happened then." Caroline asked him to stay through the hearings and promised to petition for protection against retaliation, though she could not guarantee he would escape questions about his own complicity. Hodge agreed. For the first time in decades, he seemed willing to let a court examine his work without first arranging how he would appear.

The investigators' next discovery was a bank account. Payments from several placement agencies had passed through a merchant house controlled by Shaw before reaching Vale's associates, often labeled as administrative expenses. The amounts matched entries in the leather ledger closely enough to demand explanation. They also matched the timing of transfers in which missing heirs' land claims were sold below market value. The records did not prove every official knew every abuse, but they established a financial relationship too extensive to dismiss as coincidence.

Ruth learned that Vale had begun quietly transferring property to relatives. She brought the information to Caroline rather than printing it immediately, because an inaccurate accusation could alert him without helping investigators preserve assets. Caroline notified the district judge, who authorized measures appropriate to the pending inquiry. Officials traveled to several

News in the same category

A Rancher's Daughter Hadn't Spoken in 11 Months — Then She Tasted a Poor Widow's Apple Pie

50 Part