The social cost of refusing Vivian’s patronage became clear at the next church meeting. Eliza volunteered to help organize reading lessons for children who lived too far from the school, but Vivian, who chaired the committee, said there was no need for outside assistance. “The town already has women of good standing who can manage such work,” she told the meeting. Eliza asked whether the children had been consulted about their needs. A few people smiled, and Vivian’s expression hardened. The discussion ended with no decision, though the minister’s wife later sought Eliza out and asked whether she would help unofficially. Eliza agreed, provided the classes were open to every child who needed them.
For several weeks she held a Sunday reading hour in a room behind the church, where boys and girls gathered with whatever books they had. Some were too shy to read aloud at first. Others had been told they were slow, troublesome, or too old to learn. Eliza used patient questions and stories that interested them, and found that many struggled less with words than with the shame of being corrected in front of strangers. Nathaniel drove Molly to the church each Sunday and remained afterward to help move benches. He began appearing so regularly that a few townspeople no longer bothered to disguise their curiosity.
One morning Vivian spoke to him outside the church. Eliza could not hear the words, but she saw Nathaniel’s expression close. He returned to the wagon and said only that the committee would no longer be requiring his assistance with the annual auction. She did not press him until they were on the road. “Did I cause that?” she asked. “I gave Vivian an answer she did not like.” “About what?” “About whether I should be inviting you into town so often.” Eliza looked across the fields. “She is entitled to an opinion.” “She is. She is not entitled to govern mine.”
The remark unsettled Eliza more than she expected. She had begun to understand that Nathaniel’s affection was growing, but she remained afraid that his feelings might be a reaction to pity or the novelty of her presence in a lonely household. A woman turned away at a station could be grateful for small kindnesses in ways that made judgment difficult. She refused to let gratitude stand in for desire, either in her own heart or in his. When Nathaniel asked whether he had offended her, she answered that he had not. She only needed more time to understand what she wanted.
He accepted the answer, though the effort cost him. The following weeks brought moments when either might have spoken more plainly. They rode along the orchard fence after supper, Molly trotting ahead on a pony under Daniel’s supervision. They sat across the kitchen table while Eliza helped him reconcile accounts. They walked home from church beneath a sky heavy with rain, sharing an umbrella too small for both. Each time Nathaniel was careful not to presume. Each time Eliza felt both relieved and a little disappointed, which was perhaps the best evidence that whatever was developing between them deserved honest attention.