sung to her when she could not sleep. They drew the orchard in charcoal, and Molly placed a small figure at the upstairs window of the house. “That was me,” she explained. “I waited to see Papa coming.” Eliza set the drawing aside with care. “You must have been very frightened.” Molly did not answer, but she moved closer and rested her head briefly against Eliza’s shoulder.
One morning Nathaniel found them making a list of possible adventures that required no special bravery. Molly wanted to gather fallen apples in autumn, see the creek from the footbridge, visit the far pasture once the calves had been moved, and learn to saddle a pony without relying on Daniel. Eliza wanted to take a turn in the kitchen garden without stepping into the onions. Nathaniel studied the list and crossed out the creek, the far pasture, and the pony. Molly’s expression closed. Eliza said nothing until after breakfast.
Then she found him in the harness shed. “You have crossed out everything that would require you to trust someone else with her,” she said. Nathaniel looked up sharply. “Is it your custom to lecture a man among his own saddles?” “Only when the kitchen is crowded.” He almost smiled, then saw she was serious. “You know nothing of what happened here before you arrived.” “That is true. I know only the child who lives here now.”
He turned back to the harness. “Her mother was strong. Sensible. I believed she would be here when I came home, because I had promised I would return.” Eliza waited. “She took sick while I was moving the herd. Snow closed the road. By the time a rider found us, we could not turn back without losing men and cattle. I sent word, tried another pass, buried a horse in a drift. When I reached the house, Sarah was dead.” His voice thinned on her name. “Molly stood by the window and asked me why I had brought the ribbon I promised her mother if her mother was already gone.”
Eliza imagined the child’s hands against the glass, waiting for a wagon that would arrive too late. She did not offer him reassurance he could not use. “You did come back,” she said quietly. Nathaniel stared at a buckle for so long she thought he had not heard. “Too late.” “That may be true. But she needed you after, too.” He placed the harness on its peg with care. “I cannot make her lose someone else,” he said. “No,” Eliza answered. “But if you teach her that loving someone means waiting for them to disappear, she may spend her life afraid to open a door.”
He said nothing. Eliza left him with the horses and returned to the schoolroom, where Molly was attempting to copy a poem about spring. At noon Nathaniel appeared in the doorway. “The orchard ground will be dry enough by Sunday,” he told the child. “You may walk there with Miss Rowan. If you both want to.” Molly dropped her pencil. “All the way to the fence?” “All the way.” She looked at Eliza, an enormous question in her eyes. Eliza nodded once. Molly seized her father’s hand, and he stood awkwardly while she squeezed it, learning again how to receive uncomplicated happiness.