Her riding lesson took place on a cloudy afternoon when the ranch hands were moving cattle along the lower road. Nathaniel chose a patient chestnut mare called Penny who seemed more interested in grazing than in carrying a nervous woman. Eliza stood at the mounting block and studied the saddle with frank suspicion. “I have seen furniture assembled with fewer pieces,” she remarked. Nathaniel adjusted the stirrup and promised not to ask her to move faster than a walk. “A very slow walk,” she insisted. Molly sat on the fence, delighted that another person might be less accomplished than herself.
Nathaniel placed one hand lightly against Penny’s neck and another near the back of the saddle, explaining how Eliza should sit without gripping the reins like a lifeline. “Your hands are too tight,” he said after the mare had taken four steps. “She can feel it.” “Then she knows the truth.” “The truth being?” “I would prefer to have both feet on Montana.” Penny stopped to nibble at a clump of grass, as though she agreed. Nathaniel waited until Eliza relaxed her shoulders before asking the mare to move again. By the end of the lesson she had gone twice around the corral and had even managed a turn without making the horse apologize for it.
Molly demanded that she try a trot, but Nathaniel refused on Eliza’s behalf. “Your teacher has earned her supper.” “I can manage another lesson,” Eliza protested. “I had not dismissed you,” he replied. She narrowed her eyes. “You were thinking about it.” “I was considering whether I own a shorter horse.” “Find a taller pupil.” Molly laughed so loudly that Toby looked up from the water trough. The sound seemed to settle upon the three of them, a shared joke that did not need anyone’s absence explained.
Late that evening Nathaniel came in with blood on his hand after catching it in a length of gate wire. He attempted to reach the washbasin without drawing notice, but Eliza intercepted him in the kitchen. “Sit down before you drip on Martha’s floor.” “It is only my hand.” “Then the rest of you will not mind sitting.” Martha found a clean cloth and set the kettle on the stove while Eliza examined the cut. It was not deep, though it needed thorough washing and a bandage. Nathaniel watched her work with a quiet curiosity that became something more vulnerable when her fingers touched the inside of his wrist.
Eliza understood from the way his eyes shifted that he wanted to ask about her scar. Nearly everyone eventually did, some sooner and some after a polite interval. When he opened his mouth, she said, “You may ask, if you wish.” He shook his head. “You may tell me, if you wish.” The difference was so small that another person might have missed it. She had not. He left the decision with her, and for the first time she found that the story rose to meet an invitation instead of being dragged into the open as a defense.