year at my place. I need a capable woman. You have proved yourself capable.” “I was capable when I arrived.” “Yes, but no one knew.” “You knew. You had six months of letters in which I described my skills and my life. You chose not to believe them when you saw me.”
He leaned forward. “I could provide a respectable home. I am not wealthy like Avery, but I have land, livestock, and standing here.” Eliza felt the end of the conversation approach like a train whose whistle she had heard from a distance. “You are worried that Red Creek remembers how you behaved on the platform,” she said. “You want a wife who can improve your accounts and make people forget your embarrassment.” “You twist everything.” “No. I have listened. Now I will answer.” She stood, placing one hand on the back of the chair. “I will not marry you. Please do not ask again.”
Calvin rose so quickly his chair scraped the floor. “Avery’s money has outbid my letters, then.” Eliza felt anger come, clear and welcome. “I have refused you because you were willing to shame me in public and take me back only when you believed the town had changed its mind. Mr. Avery has not bought my answer. I have given it freely.” At that moment Nathaniel appeared in the doorway, having returned earlier than either of them expected. He did not step into the room. “You have heard her, Pike,” he said quietly. “It is time you went home.”
Calvin left without offering Eliza a farewell. The sound of his horse on the gravel faded, leaving only the kitchen clock and Martha’s determined clatter at the stove. Nathaniel waited until Eliza looked at him. “I did not mean to listen,” he said. “There is little privacy in a house with a kitchen at its heart.” Eliza sighed. “Then you heard all of it?” “Enough to be ashamed of men in general.” She smiled despite herself. “I would not make quite such a sweeping statement. There are some tolerable specimens.” He lowered his eyes. “You are generous.” “Only when the evidence supports it.”
That evening Molly asked whether Mr. Pike would return. Eliza said she did not think so. “Was he the man who said you were not pretty enough to be married?” The question came without malice, and that made it more painful. “He decided he did not wish to marry me,” Eliza answered. “He said it badly.” Molly thought for a while. “Then he is very foolish,” she said. “There are many things about people besides their faces.” “There are.” “And your face looks like yours.” Eliza leaned across the table and kissed her forehead. “That is a sensible observation, Miss Avery.”