"I used to think people had to pick me because I was useful," Clara said. "Or because they couldn't find somebody better."
"And now?"
She watched Benjamin run, his blond hair flying in the wind. "Now I think I get to choose back."
Samuel smiled. "That's the best part."
They picnicked beneath the cottonwoods by the creek. Benjamin showed Clara a new book, Helen brought fresh bread, and George announced that his rooster had finally lost its argument with the barn door. Samuel told a story about Lily painting a horse green because she believed it looked bored with brown. Everyone laughed, and Clara felt no need to conceal the sadness that followed. She had learned that remembering the dead and enjoying the living were not opposing loyalties.
After the meal, Clara wrote a letter to her mother beneath the shade of a tree. She had written many letters since coming west, but this one felt different. She told Rose about Benjamin's new parents, about the dog who considered himself a soldier, about Samuel and Amos and Mrs. Calloway, about the judge and the papers and the way the garden soil warmed in April. She told her that she still remembered the fire and sometimes woke afraid. Then she wrote the words she had not dared to believe on the train: I am safe. I have a home. Benjamin and I are still brother and sister, and there are people who love us both.
She folded the letter and tucked it beside the old one in a tin box she kept beneath her bed. In the evenings she sometimes took them out and read them together, the living words of a mother who had died and the new words of a daughter who had survived. She had chosen to use the surname Reed in school, while keeping Finch as part of her name on the papers so that no one could erase the family she came from. Samuel never insisted that one name replace the other. He said she had enough room in herself for all the people who had loved her.
That summer she began helping Miss Whitcomb teach younger children to read. One afternoon a timid girl entered the classroom with a badly mended dress and a habit of keeping her face turned toward the wall. Clara recognized the posture immediately. She sat beside the child, introduced herself, and asked whether she would like to choose a book. The girl said she did not know which one was allowed. Clara opened the cupboard and told her she could look at every title before deciding.
She thought of the depot, where adults had looked at children and chosen among them as if comparing goods. At school she wanted things to be different. She wanted children to be asked what they knew, what frightened them, and what they hoped to learn. Samuel said she could not change every institution in the country. She agreed. But she could make certain that at least one room in Harmon did not treat silence as consent.