She thought about the east-facing window, about Benjamin's striped stone in her pocket, and about the way Amos talked to his horses as though expecting answers. For the first time, she imagined a life that would not be built entirely around what had burned. The thought was hopeful and frightening in equal measure.
On Thursday, the sheriff arrived with another deputy and asked Samuel to accompany him into town. The deputy held a paper alleging interference with an authorized placement and disturbing the peace at the depot. Samuel read it carefully, then asked to see the signed complaint and the magistrate's order. The sheriff, Caleb Morris, was a thin man who took pride in tidy paperwork and disliked being required to explain it. He showed the documents and stated that a hearing had been scheduled. Samuel asked whether he was under arrest or merely requested to appear. Morris admitted that an arrest warrant had been issued on a sworn statement from Greeley's assistant, who claimed Samuel had threatened violence at the platform.
Amos moved toward the barn, where his shotgun rested above the feed-room door. Samuel stopped him with a glance. "No," he said. "We've done nothing that needs a rifle."
He turned back to the sheriff. "I'll come willingly. But you will leave the girl with Mrs. Calloway, who has already agreed to look after her. And I want it written that I surrendered peacefully."
Sheriff Morris seemed disappointed. He had brought a deputy expecting a rancher determined to make trouble. Samuel instead asked him to wait while Weller was summoned by messenger. When the lawyer arrived, he pointed out that the allegation concerned words spoken in public before several witnesses and that Samuel had already appeared voluntarily at a court hearing. The sheriff answered that he still had a warrant to execute. Samuel said he understood and stepped into the carriage without arguing.
Clara watched from the porch holding a folded kitchen towel. Samuel looked back before the wagon moved. "Remember our promise," he called. "We tell the truth and let the papers do their work. I'll be home when I can."
After the carriage disappeared, she realized that all the kindness of the previous week had not cured her fear of being left. She stood in the yard until Mrs. Calloway took the towel from her hands. Then she walked into Lily's room and sat on the edge of the bed, listening for the sound of a wagon that did not return before dark.
Clara wanted to believe that Samuel had been taken because of Greeley's lies. But her mind kept offering a harsher explanation: perhaps choosing her had been a mistake, and now that the cost was plain, any sensible man would stop. She had seen adults surrender difficult children to institutions for less. She wondered whether Judge Bell would look at Samuel's arrest and decide the ranch was not a safe home. She wondered whether Helen Cooper would be ordered to return Benjamin. The fears multiplied because each one gave her something else to lose.