By Saturday, word of Samuel's arrest had reached neighboring towns. Some people assumed the charges proved he had done something improper. Others had known him for years and spoke publicly in his defense. A farmer whose children had been placed through the same agent remembered paying for supplies that were never delivered. A widow said Greeley had demanded an additional fee before allowing her to adopt a child whom she had already cared for during the winter. Two families reported receiving children whose ages did not match the paperwork. Weller collected their statements, but he did not promise that every accusation would stand up in court.
Clara sat at Mrs. Calloway's kitchen table while each witness came and went. She heard adults argue over documents and methods instead of assuming a child ought to obey whoever held the largest ledger. It made her nervous to be at the center of so much attention. Yet she also felt the first stirrings of anger that had somewhere useful to go. Her suffering was not a private defect; it was connected to choices made by people who had expected no one to examine them.
On Sunday evening, Amos brought news from Harmon. Samuel had been released on bond arranged by Weller and would return before nightfall. Clara had been helping mend a horse blanket when she heard the wagon. She ran outside without her shawl and stopped halfway across the yard, suddenly uncertain whether she was permitted to show how glad she was. Samuel climbed down, looked at her, and opened both arms. She walked into them before she could argue herself out of it.
"You came back," she whispered.
"I said I'd try."
"You said you'd be home when you could."
"Then I kept the promise properly," he said. "It took longer than I wanted, and I'm sorry you had to wonder."
She stepped away, embarrassed by her own tears. Samuel did not seem embarrassed. He thanked Mrs. Calloway, asked after the horses, and sat down for supper without explaining the courthouse at once. Clara was grateful. It told her he still saw the ranch as a home, not merely a stage on which to argue with Greeley. When the dishes were cleared, he asked what she had been doing. She told him about the faint writing and the telegram to New York. His expression changed from pride to something quieter. "You gave us a road we didn't know was there," he said.
That night Samuel repaired the loose latch on the back door. Clara stood beside him holding the lantern, studying how he fitted the new screw without splitting the wood. She asked whether Lily had held a lantern for him in the same way. Samuel smiled. "Whenever she could persuade me she wasn't tired. She liked the tools more than the result."
"Did it hurt to see me in her room?" Clara asked.
The screwdriver stopped moving. Samuel considered his answer with the care she had come to expect from him. "Sometimes I walk past the door and remember that she used to sleep there," he said. "That hurts. But seeing you there isn't what caused it. You're not borrowing happiness from her. There is room for both of you in my life."