Greeley was called next. He described a long career devoted to finding homes for unfortunate children. He told the judge that his charitable purpose had been misunderstood and that Clara had been assigned to a school that could provide practical training and moral discipline. Weller asked whether the institution had already received her name. Greeley said yes. Had it paid him? The agent replied that the society received only ordinary transportation reimbursement. Weller requested the relevant accounting entries. Greeley said they were kept in Topeka and not available.
"Then you cannot tell us today whether the Academy paid five dollars, fifty dollars, or nothing," Weller said.
"I can assure the court the arrangements were proper."
"An assurance is not an account, Mr. Greeley."
The judge instructed Weller to keep to questions. Weller nodded and asked whether Clara's age card was correct. Greeley said the figure had been supplied in New York. Had he reviewed the original record? He claimed he had. Why, then, did the Coopers' paperwork state that Benjamin had no surviving siblings? Greeley shifted in his chair. Perhaps, he said, the children were unrelated and had confused matters through their closeness during travel. Clara felt Benjamin stiffen beside Helen. She reached across the small gap between benches and touched his sleeve.
Weller asked permission to introduce the mother's letter as preliminary evidence of their relationship. Greeley objected that it could have been written by anyone. Judge Bell agreed that it would need verification before carrying decisive weight, but allowed the document into the record. Clara watched a clerk place the letter beside other papers on the judge's desk. It seemed too small a thing to challenge a man with an office, an organization, and a ledger. Yet it was the only surviving piece of her mother's handwriting, and she had carried it across half a continent for this exact reason.
When Samuel took the witness chair, Weller asked what he had intended to do at the depot. He said he had come looking for a child who needed a family, not an employee. He admitted he had initially asked about a younger boy, then explained that Clara was the one he found standing without an offer. He had not known about her scar before he saw her; he had not known about Benjamin until she told him. What he knew was that the girl answered questions clearly, that her age card was wrong, and that the receiving arrangement seemed to involve labor rather than education.
Greeley's lawyer asked whether Samuel intended to make Clara work on his ranch. Samuel answered that children living on farms often helped with chores, and that there was a difference between learning to care for a horse and being contracted to labor in a factory. Did he have any children of his own? Samuel paused. "I had a daughter," he said. "She died four years ago."
"So you are seeking a replacement?"
Samuel looked toward Clara before answering. "No. Nobody could replace Lily. Miss Finch is a person of her own. I don't want her to become anyone else."