During dinner, George Cooper asked Samuel about the court hearing. He had discovered that the placement form for Benjamin listed the boy as having no known siblings. He brought it out from a cupboard and placed it on the table. Clara read it, her mouth growing dry. The description did not merely omit her name; it declared that a search of the original family records had found no surviving relations. George said he had been told the charitable society took great care with documentation. "I believed it," he admitted. "I wanted to believe it. We had waited so long for a child."
Samuel did not condemn him. "Then we find the original records and see what they say." George nodded. Helen reached across the table and placed her hand near Clara's, giving her the choice whether to take it. Clara did. Something about that gesture made her believe Helen had meant what she said at the depot. The woman wanted Benjamin to be safe more than she wanted an easy story about how he came to her.
By Monday morning, however, the matter had become more difficult. Greeley had sent a telegram to the county clerk asserting that Samuel had obtained custody through threats and that the girl had been promised to a legitimate industrial institution. A second telegram, supposedly from the institution's superintendent, claimed expenses had already been incurred preparing her place. Attorney Bell advised Samuel to bring every document he possessed, even the ordinary grocery receipts showing that he maintained a household. He also advised him to engage independent counsel, a recommendation Samuel finally accepted. A young attorney named Thomas Weller joined them without asking for a large advance.
Clara disliked the way everyone began speaking of guardianship as a transaction. She understood that law required records, but she had been measured, weighed, renamed, and assigned so often that another set of papers felt like a cage. Weller noticed her expression and asked if she would prefer to speak privately before the hearing. With Mrs. Calloway present, Clara showed him her mother's letter and described the night Greeley had changed her age card. The lawyer listened without interrupting and made a careful copy. Then he returned the original to her, asking whether she wanted to keep carrying it herself.
"It's mine," she said.
"Then it stays yours," he replied.
The first hearing lasted less than an hour. Judge Bell was a heavyset man with a measured voice and spectacles he pushed onto his forehead whenever witnesses tried to evade a question. He heard Samuel's petition, reviewed the temporary agreement signed at Harmon, and instructed the clerk to request the agency's original placement records. He was unwilling to decide permanent guardianship without verifying those records and Clara's situation. He also ordered that her current lodging remain undisturbed until a further hearing, provided Mrs. Calloway and the county welfare committee continued to check on her circumstances.