Accidentally? Naomi nodded. Your honor, at this time, I would like to introduce plaintiff's exhibit nine into evidence. It is an audio file subpoenaed directly from the Axon cloud servers, retrieved three weeks ago by a third-party forensic audio technician. Pendleton scrambled over his desk.
Your honor, we were not provided with this in discovery. That is false, your honor, Naomi said, effortlessly pulling a certified mail receipt from her pocket. It was included in supplemental discovery batch D, delivered to Mr. Pendleton's office 14 days ago. If opposing counsel failed to review the flash drive labeled Axon cloud backup, that is not the plaintiff's burden. Judge Harrison looked at the receipt, then glared at Pendleton.
Is this true, counselor? Pendleton stammered, looking at his paralegal, who was furiously clicking through a laptop. The paralegal went white and nodded. It It appears it was in the file, your honor, but we object to its admission. It lacks foundation.
Ms. Bennett laid the foundation when she established the technical specifications of the camera, the judge snapped. You opened the door when you let your client testify about the malfunction. The evidence is admitted. Play the audio, Ms. Bennett. Naomi walked over to the AV cart.
She didn't rush. She let the anticipation stretch. She let Reed sit in the witness box and marinate in the terror of the unknown. He was staring at her hands, his breathing shallow. He thought he had covered his tracks.
He had smashed the camera. He had written the report. He had filed the paperwork. He was untouchable, until he wasn't. Naomi clicked the mouse.
At first, the speakers hissed with the sound of static and heavy driving rain. Then, the rhythmic thwack, thwack, thwack of windshield wipers. "License and registration." Reed's voice boomed through the courtroom, distorted but unmistakable. "Officer, why did you pull me over?" Naomi's recorded voice was remarkably calm, lacking any of the erratic hysteria Reed had described. "I said, give me your damn license." "I am reaching into my jacket pocket for my wallet.
My hands are visible." "Stop reaching! Stop reaching!" The audio captured the terrifying, violent explosion of breaking glass. Several jurors flinched in their seats. Then came the sound of screaming wind, heavy scuffling, and a wet, sickening thud. "Get on the ground, face in the dirt!" Reed's voice roared.
"My hands are behind my back, you're breaking my wrist!" Then a clattering sound, the body camera hitting the asphalt. The courtroom was dead silent. The audio continued to play. For 10 seconds, there was only the sound of rain, Naomi's heavy breathing, and a soft whimpering from the pain of a broken bone. Then came the sound of a heavy boot scraping on wet pavement, a sharp, violent crack.
The sound of plastic shattering under immense weight, but the audio didn't cut out. It muffled, as if the microphone was now pressed into the wet street, but it kept recording. "Stupid [ __ ]!" Reed's voice muttered on the tape, crystal clear despite the crushed casing. "Think you can talk back to me?" Then another voice entered the audio, another officer. "Danny, you good?