Ms. Bennett, I am not finished. Higgins snapped his mouth shut. There was an authority in her voice that terrified him. It wasn't the authority of a badge or a title. It was the unyielding authority of a woman who had survived the worst they had to offer and realized she was no longer afraid of them.
I will not sign a non-disclosure agreement, Naomi stated. The audio tape remains public record. The transcript remains public record and my settlement number is not 1.5 million. It is 4 million dollars. Pendleton choked on a breath.
4 million? That's absurd. No jury will give you that for a broken wrist. They won't give it to me for a broken wrist, Naomi corrected. They will give it to me in punitive damages because your department has a documented systemic practice of fabricating evidence, which your own officer just confessed to under oath.
4 million triggers a mandatory audit by the Department of Justice. It forces a consent decree. It puts a federal monitor inside your precinct. Higgins slammed his hand on the table. We will never agree to that.
Never. Then we go back into that courtroom and I give my closing argument, Naomi said, picking up her pen. I will play that tape one more time for the jury. I will remind them that Daniel Reed invoked the Fifth Amendment and I will ask them for 6 million. And looking at their faces 20 minutes ago, I think they just might give it to me.
She stood up smoothing the front of her charcoal suit. Oh, and Mr. Higgins, I want Reed's badge, not a quiet retirement. I want him terminated for cause today, stripped of his pension, banned from law enforcement in this state. If those terms are not met in the next 5 minutes, I will see you in front of the judge. She turned and walked out of the room.
She didn't look back. She didn't wait to see Higgins collapse into his chair rubbing his temples knowing he had just lost a war he didn't even realize he was fighting. Courtroom 4B was packed to the gills. The word had spread during the recess. Law clerks, off-duty public defenders, and local reporters had crammed into the wooden pews, smelling blood in the water.
Judge Harrison took the bench. He looked down at the defense table. Arthur Pendleton sat alone. Officer Daniel Reed was nowhere to be seen. "Mr. Pendleton," Judge Harrison rumbled, "has the defense reached a decision on how they wish to proceed?" Pendleton stood up.
He looked like he had aged 5 years in 30 minutes. He didn't look at the jury. He couldn't. "Your honor," Pendleton's voice cracked, he cleared his throat and tried again, "the defense rests." A low murmur rolled through the gallery. They were offering no rebuttal, no character witnesses for Reed, no expert testimony to justify the force.