A Cop Thought His Badge Made Him Untouchable — Then the Woman He Arrested Played a Recording in Court

Chapter 2

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"I ordered her to show her hands," Reed continued, his tone injected with just the right amount of retrospective gravity. "She refused. I was forced to break the driver's side window, open the door, and extract her from the vehicle to secure the scene. She violently resisted. That is how she sustained the bruising to her face and the fractured wrist.

You used the minimum amount of force necessary to secure a non-compliant, potentially armed suspect. Yes, sir. I followed my training to the letter. Thank you, officer. Nothing further.

Pendleton smiled warmly at the jury and took his seat. Judge Thomas Harrison, a man who looked like he had been born in a judicial robe and was eternally exhausted by it, peered over his reading glasses. "Ms. Bennett," the judge droned, "you are representing yourself in this matter. Are you prepared for cross-examination?" Naomi placed her silver pen softly on her legal pad. The sound was barely audible, yet it seemed to cut through the white noise of the courtroom.

"I am, your honor." She stood up. She didn't carry any notes to the podium. She didn't bring a binder. She just walked to the center of the floor, the heels of her shoes clicking a slow, deliberate rhythm on the hardwood. Reed watched her approach.

He felt a flicker of annoyance. Usually, pro se plaintiffs, citizens who foolishly represented themselves, were an absolute joke. They stammered. They got emotional. They argued with the judge and got held in contempt.

But Naomi didn't look flustered. She looked at Reed the way a mechanic looks at a broken engine. "Officer Reed," she began, her voice calm, projecting effortlessly to the back row of the gallery. "You just testified that you followed your training to the letter. Is that correct?" Reed squared his jaw.

"Yes, ma'am. And you have been a patrol officer for 12 years? That's right. So, you are thoroughly familiar with department policy regarding traffic stops, use of force, and evidence preservation?" "Intimately familiar. Good." Naomi rested her hands on the edges of the podium.

"Let's talk about the rain." Reed blinked. The rain? Out of all the things she could have attacked, the broken window, the fractured wrist, the phantom gun he claimed he thought she had, she was starting with the weather. "It was raining heavily, you said." Naomi continued. "Yes, a downpour.

Visibility was low, very low." Naomi nodded slowly. "Officer Reed, you testified during direct examination that you saw my vehicle swerving over the yellow line from approximately 200 yards behind me. Is that accurate?" "I was behind you, yes. I saw you swerving through heavy rain with low visibility." "My cruiser has specialized headlights, Ms. Bennett." Reed offered a patronizing half smile. "I know what I saw." "I'm sure you do." Naomi took a single step to her left, moving out from behind the podium.

"In your police report, plaintiff's exhibit four, your honor, which I will display on the monitors, you wrote that you pulled me over at 11:42 p.m." The monitors in the courtroom flickered to life, displaying a blown-up highlighted section of Reed's handwritten report. "Yes," Reed said, "11:42 p.m. And in this report, you stated that upon approaching my window, you immediately detected the strong odor of unburnt marijuana." Pendleton half stood from his chair. "Objection, your honor. Relevance.

News in the same category

A Cop Thought His Badge Made Him Untouchable — Then the Woman He Arrested Played a Recording in Court

15 Part