No drugs were found in the vehicle." "That is exactly the relevance, your honor." Naomi fired back, not taking her eyes off Reed. "The officer used the alleged scent to justify the escalation of the stop. I am establishing the physical impossibility of that claim." Judge Harrison waved a hand. "Overruled. You may answer, officer." Reed shifted in his seat.
The leather squeaked sharply. "Yes, I smelled marijuana. People who use drugs often try to hide them. Just because I didn't find them doesn't mean you weren't smoking or didn't throw them out. Naomi offered a thin razor-sharp smile.
Let's examine the physics of that, officer. You testified it was a heavy downpour. You testified I refused to roll my window down more than 1 in. That's right. You were uncooperative.
So, through a 1-in crack in the glass in a torrential rainstorm with heavy winds blowing crossways off the highway, you managed to detect the scent of unburnt marijuana from a car that contained no marijuana. Reed's jaw tightened. I have a highly trained sense of smell. A single suppressed laugh escaped from the back of the gallery. Reed's eyes darted toward the sound, a flash of pure anger crossing his face before he smoothed it over.
A highly trained sense of smell, Naomi repeated, tasting the words. Is that an official certification at the academy, officer? Objection, badgering, Pendleton snapped. Sustained. Move on, Ms. Bennett.
Let's move to the moment you broke my window, Naomi said, her voice dropping a fraction of an octave, losing the sarcastic edge and replacing it with something cold and metallic. You testified I was reaching frantically under the passenger seat. You were. And you feared for your life. I did.
Officer Reed, what is the make and model of the car I was driving that night? Reed frowned. A black sedan, a Honda Accord, I believe. A 2018 Honda Accord, Naomi corrected. Plaintiff's exhibit 7, your honor.
The interior specifications of a 2018 Honda Accord. Another document flashed on the screens. It was a schematic from the manufacturer. Officer, are you aware that the 2018 Honda Accord has a solid plastic casing bolted directly to the floorboard extending from the front of the passenger seat down to the carpet housing the electronic seat motors. Reed stared at the screen.
The confidence that had buoyed him for the last 2 hours began to leak just a drop at a time. I'm a cop, not a mechanic. You don't need to be a mechanic to have eyes, Naomi stated flatly. If there is a solid plastic wall blocking the space beneath the passenger seat, how exactly was I reaching under it? You were reaching toward it.
Reed corrected himself quickly, his voice rising in volume. In a high-stress situation, things move fast. You lunged toward the passenger side. I made a split-second decision to neutralize a threat. You made a split-second decision to shatter my window with your baton, drag me out by my hair, and pin me face-first into the wet asphalt, Naomi said, the words hitting like hammer strikes.