she must surrender every other part of herself. She studied, taught, and formed friendships with people who understood her circumstances without turning her into a cautionary tale. Nathaniel listened with a sorrow that no longer required him to imagine her life as empty in order to prove she had loved him. The distinction freed them both.
Meanwhile, Evelyn's sisters visited often enough that the servants began keeping a spare set of practice gloves in the hall. Isabel considered every arrangement an opportunity for improvement. Rosalind delighted in finding the estate's forgotten doors and occasionally embarrassed the head gardener by observing that an ornamental hedge concealed a damaged drain. Nathaniel became accustomed to being questioned by women who liked him yet refused to regard affection as a reason for politeness without substance. He discovered that he enjoyed their company most when he stopped trying to impress them. The sisters noticed and rewarded the change with increasing irreverence.
In December, Thomas Bell asked Nathaniel for permission to marry a young woman from the next village. He expected the usual questions about earnings and conduct. Nathaniel asked those things, then surprised the footman by inquiring whether his intended had been invited to decide what kind of life she wanted. Thomas blushed and said they had talked at length about it. His fiancée intended to continue her work as a seamstress after the wedding. Nathaniel wished them well and asked whether a modest wedding gift would be better spent on furniture or tools for her work. Thomas answered that tools would delight her. Nathaniel told Evelyn about the conversation that evening and found her smiling before he reached the end.
The season also brought memories neither husband nor wife had learned to dismiss. A sudden noise at the stable gates could still make Evelyn's breath catch. When a rider approached unexpectedly along the western road, Nathaniel sometimes felt his hand move toward a weapon that was no longer there. They refused to make the sensations shameful. They spoke of them, changed their arrangements where reasonable, and continued living. The presence of fear did not mean the life they had chosen was failing. It meant that an ugly beginning had left marks, and those marks could be treated with the same patience they offered a repaired parasol.
As their anniversary approached, Lady Augusta proposed a grand dinner with musicians and an elaborate confection shaped like the family crest. Evelyn said that if the crest was edible, it might finally prove useful. Nathaniel suggested that they celebrate quietly, without refusing the household a small supper. Catherine advised that the day should belong to the two people who had lived it. They agreed to ride the wedding road again, not in defiance of the attack but because they wished to replace the last memory of that place with another of their own choosing. The decision seemed simple when spoken aloud. Evelyn knew it would require courage of a quieter kind.
Winter came and with it the anniversary of their wedding, Evelyn woke to rain tapping the glass. the same thin rain that had silvered the oak road after the chapel. She turned in bed and found Nathaniel awake beside her. Thinking she asked, "Unfortunately, about the first carriage ride." "Ah, I was unbearable.