Cole could feel the attention of the whole room settling on him the way it always did at this point in the story, the way a crowd settles around a corner where something is about to happen. He had two choices, same as every time. He could get up and leave, or he could tell it again. He set his beer down. "You want to hear it?"
Cole said, "or you want to keep performing for the room?" Drew's smile thinned. "I've heard it, Cole." "You've heard a version of it." "You've heard the parts you were listening for."
Cole turned on his stool to face the room properly. The movement was slow. His back had not been forgiving him lately, but he made it deliberate. "You want to sit there and decide what's real from a stool you've been on for 3 hours? Fine, but that's not the same as listening."
"Then tell us something new," said a voice from the back, Marcus, one of the card players, a steady man in his 40s who didn't usually involve himself in these exchanges. "If the story's real, Cole, there's got to be something you haven't said yet. It was a fair challenge. Cole recognized it as fair. He also recognized that it was the kind of challenge that once made had to be answered or surrendered.
He looked at Marcus for a long moment. The name, Cole said, the third man, the one in the suit who ran. You've mentioned him before, Drew said. I've mentioned that he existed. I've never said the name.
The room went still in a different way than it had been still before. Why not? Marcus asked. Because until I could prove it, Cole said. Saying the name would just be another detail nobody believed.
He paused. The same way nobody believes the notebook. The same way nobody believed Daniel Marsh bled out on my jacket in a desert parking lot while I held his ribs together with my bare hands and promised him I'd find his daughter. Cole, Drew started. I promised a dying man, Cole said, and his voice had dropped to something quieter and more dangerous than anything in the room, that I would find his daughter.
I have been trying to keep that promise for 40 years, and every week I come in here and I tell this story because the only way to find someone, the only way is to keep saying the name of what you're looking for until the universe gets tired of you and puts it in front of you. He picked up his beer. So, you want to call me crazy? Go ahead. I've been called crazy by men I respected.
You don't qualify. But if any of you, any one of you wants to actually hear what happened in that parking lot, I'll tell it. And this time I'll say the name. Silence. Drew looked at his glass.