"He's a contact," Marcus said, "someone I've been talking to about your story, Cole, for the past 3 months." He exhaled. "I've been trying to verify what you've been telling us." "I didn't tell you because because I wasn't sure I'd find anything. I didn't want to give you hope and then come back with nothing."
Cole stared at him. "You've been investigating," Cole said. "I've been trying to," Marcus said. "And the man in the back, his name is Frank Dellinger. He's a retired prosecutor out of Phoenix.
I found him through a contact in the court system." He paused. "He knows the case, Cole, the federal case your man Daniel was tied to. He was a junior prosecutor on it in 1986. He left the office in '89.
He's been Marcus stopped. "Frank, come up here." The man walked forward. He was 65, maybe 67, with a gray suit and the unhurried movement of someone who'd spent decades in courtrooms and understood that the room always feels what you feel before you say it. He stopped a few feet from Cole and looked at him for a moment.
Then he looked at the oilcloth. "That's the Marsh notebook," he said. Not a question. Cole looked at Marcus. "I described it to him," Marcus said, "from what you told us."
"That notebook," Frank Dellinger said quietly, "was listed as evidence in a federal case that was never fully prosecuted. The case collapsed in 1987 when the primary witness died in custody, ruled accidental. Three attorneys were investigated in connection with possible jury tampering. One of them was Walter Pena." He looked at Cole directly.
"I never believed it was accidental, but I was 28 years old and I had no evidence and no standing and a lot of pressure to let it go. A pause. I let it go. The room was completely silent. "I've regretted it," he said every year since.
Cole looked at the oilcloth on the table. He looked at Mara. He looked at Frank Dellinger. This man he hadn't known existed this morning standing in his club on a Tuesday afternoon like the universe had decided it was finally done making Cole wait. He picked up the oilcloth.
"Then let's not waste any more time," he said. Reaper's voice came from across the room. "Cole?" Cole looked at him. Reaper's face had done something Cole had never seen it do in 12 years.
It had let go of everything it usually held in place. The amusement, the control, the patient practice management of every room he entered, all of it gone replaced by something raw and simple. "I'm sorry," Reaper said, "for the laughing, for" He stopped, started again. "I should have listened." Cole looked at him for a long moment.
"Yeah," he said, "you should have." He didn't say it with anger, just with the truth of it, the plain and unvarnished truth, the way you say things that have waited long enough for softening and are done waiting. He tucked the oilcloth back inside his jacket. Then his phone rang. Unknown number.