They Mocked an Old Biker's Story for 40 Years — Then a Woman Walked Into Their Club

Chapter 25

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

He took in Dellinger. He took in Mara. Then he looked at Cole and for the first time since he walked through that door, something moved across his face that wasn't composure. Because Cole was looking at him the way a man looks at something he has been looking for across 40 years of desert and doubt and Tuesday nights of laughter. Not with hatred, not with triumph, with recognition.

"Walter Pena," Cole said, "you look older than I expected." Pena looked at him for a long moment. "You look exactly the same," he said, and the compliment, if that's what it was, carried something underneath it that was not a compliment at all. He stepped forward into the room. The two men who'd entered with him stayed near the door.

Outside the other vehicles had not disgorged anyone yet. "I told you on the phone that this could end quietly," Pena said. His voice filled the bar the same way it had filled the phone-controlled space as the voice of a man who charged $400 an hour to use it and considered that a bargain. "I came here personally to make that offer again because I believe in giving people the opportunity to make good decisions before decisions get made for them." "That's generous," Cole said.

"I'm a generous man," Pena said without irony. "The woman with the file," Cole said nodding at Mara, "the man who spent 40 years keeping the notebook safe, the retired prosecutor who never stopped believing the case should have been made." He kept his eyes on Pena. "And you walked in here personally with three vehicles and hired muscle to offer us all a quiet ending." Cole tilted his head.

"You're scared." Pena's expression didn't change, but something shifted behind it, the slightest realignment of whatever he kept locked behind that face. "I'm cautious," he said. "There's a difference." "You're scared," Cole said again, "because for 40 years the only thing that stood between you and that notebook was time and disbelief.

Time has run out and somebody finally believes." He paused. "That somebody is now 60 minutes away." Pena looked at Dellinger. "Frank," he said, "you should have stayed retired."

"Probably," Dellinger said. "I've been making that decision wrong for 30 years. I'm going to try getting it right." Pena turned back to Cole. The composure was still in place, but it required something now you could see it requiring something where before it had been effortless.

"Here is what will happen if you pursue this," he said. "The notebook will be challenged. The authentication process takes months. My attorneys will file motions that delay every step. The woman's mother's journal is second-hand testimony from a deceased person with a documented history of psychological instability.

Yes, I know Caroline Marsh's history. I've known it for 30 years. I've kept it documented specifically for this reason. Every delay, every challenge, every complication, I have prepared for all of it." He paused.

"You are 71 years old, Ethan. Do you want to spend the remaining years of your life in a legal process that I will ensure is as long and difficult as I can possibly make it." The room was absolutely silent. Cole looked at him. He thought about Daniel Marsh's hands in the dark gripping his wrist.

News in the same category

They Mocked an Old Biker's Story for 40 Years — Then a Woman Walked Into Their Club

45 Part