The second morning she asked Mary to move her possessions to the small chamber at the eastern end of the house. Mary carried the sewing basket first because Eleanor could not bear to watch her marriage reduced to dresses and books. She did not make the choice to punish Julian. She needed a door she could shut without wondering whether the next interruption would be another accusation.
At the other end of the corridor, Julian watched her chamber being prepared and felt betrayed a second time. It took him a day to understand the difference between being abandoned and being given distance. Even then he did not know how to let her have it without feeling his dignity had been reduced. Pride made him wait. Fear made him speak again.
"Until this matter is settled," he told her in his study, "I would prefer you not to leave Wrenford. We do not know whether the man is dangerous."
Eleanor became utterly still. "Prefer?"
"I am concerned for your safety."
"Then tell me your concern. Do not dress an order as affection."
"You know I cannot ignore an unknown man in your room."
"And you know that the estate is my home, Julian. A home is not a place where one person issues permissions and calls the other protected."
He heard how authoritarian he sounded and tried to correct himself. He said he meant only until the roads were safe. She asked whether the roads had been safe enough for his unannounced return. He had no answer. When she said, "Do not call control protection simply because you are afraid," he felt the words strike somewhere beneath his defenses.
"I am afraid," he admitted.
For a heartbeat her expression softened. He thought she might finally explain everything. Instead she said that fear did not entitle him to the truth of another person's secret. She would not leave in defiance or remain in submission. She would decide when she wished to travel, just as she had before the quarrel. Julian turned away before he could make another demand. It was the first time in his life he had recognized an order as a mistake while it was still in the air between them.
The rumor traveled through Wrenford on a wet Tuesday and reached the village before the week was out. Mrs. Pell, the housekeeper, heard two maids whispering that the duchess had been visited by a gentleman in the small hours. She dismissed the talk as impertinence, but her warning arrived too late to stop it. A footman told a groom, the groom spoke to his sister at the baker's, and by Friday the tale had grown a midnight carriage, a stolen kiss, and a concealed pistol, none of which had ever existed. Julian ordered the servants to stop discussing private affairs. He did not publicly defend his wife because, he admitted only to himself, he was still unsure whether he could.