She carried the box to Julian's study on the following evening. She did not intend to reveal Gabriel, and she did not believe the gesture would resolve the danger. She wanted to see whether Julian could choose not to use an opportunity for inspection. She set the box on the desk between them, placed the key beside it, and waited while he looked from her face to the polished walnut lid.
"You have wondered what I keep in here," she said.
"Yes."
"Then you may open it."
He frowned. "Do you wish me to?"
"No."
"Why offer?"
"Because you should know that I could surrender my private life to satisfy your doubt. I do not believe I ought to be required to do so."
Julian studied the key. His hand moved once toward it, stopped, and remained flat on the blotter. "If I don't open it, will you tell me what I need to know?"
"Not tonight."
"Then your test is unfair."
"It is not a test," Eleanor replied. "It is a choice. I hope you can recognize the difference."
She left the box and key on the desk until morning. Julian did not open it. He spent hours sitting in front of it, however, and Eleanor knew from the weariness around his eyes that restraint had cost him dearly. When she retrieved it after breakfast, he said nothing. She found no comfort in that silence because trust acquired through exhaustion was not quite the same as trust freely given.
Julian himself was beginning to recognize the damage his questions had done. He had not found evidence of adultery. He had found a frightened maid, a resentful housekeeper, an uncooperative gardener, and a wife who no longer waited for him in the library. At first he blamed secrecy for each loss. Then he noticed that he had created most of the circumstances that hurt. He might not have understood why Eleanor would not speak, but he did understand that servants would interpret his suspicion as an instruction. As duke, he could remain silent and still make a declaration.
One evening he summoned Mrs. Pell and told her to restore Eleanor's authority over the household to the fullest extent. The housekeeper listened politely, then asked a question that unsettled him. "Has Her Grace lost any authority, sir?" Julian realized that his order itself assumed a reduction he had never been entitled to make. He corrected himself. Mrs. Pell accepted the correction, then said, with enough bravery to endanger her position, that the duchess had been treated unkindly by gossip the duke could have stopped. Julian asked whether the housekeeper believed Eleanor unfaithful. Mrs. Pell answered that she had served the family for thirty-one years and had learned to know the difference between ignorance and evidence.
"You know your wife," she said. "Or you did."
After she left, Julian walked through the east wing and found Eleanor's old room empty. The basin had been removed and the stained linen disposed of, but a faint mark remained on the rug near the bed. He stood where the stranger had stood and tried to see the room without