He saw her waiting beside the garden gate in a dark green cloak with the hood lowered. The sight unsettled him more than it had on their wedding day. She looked healthy, wind-reddened, and comfortable in a place that did not belong to him. Julian felt a pang of selfish disappointment, then recognized that her comfort was what he had claimed to want. He greeted her gently and offered his arm. She took it after a moment, and they began walking toward the cliffs.
For the first hour they spoke of almost everything except their marriage. She asked after Mary and Mrs. Pell, the orchard, the mare's foal, and the widow in the west cottages. He reported the repairs and told her that the steward had begun to disagree with him in meetings, which he considered progress. Eleanor laughed in surprise. The sound nearly stopped him in the path. When the wind became cold they sat behind a low wall above the sea, and she asked the question he had been expecting since he left Wrenford.
"Suppose you saw another stranger leaving my chamber at dawn," she said. "Suppose every circumstance looked exactly as it did that morning. What would you do?"
Julian looked down at his hands. He wanted to produce an answer so generous and precise that she would have to believe him. Then he remembered how easily words had once served his pride. "I would ask who he was," he said. "I would tell you the sight frightened me. If you could not answer, I would not insist that fear made you guilty. I would help with whatever danger we could see and leave you room to speak when you could."
"And if you were wrong to trust me?"
He considered. "Then I should have to bear being wrong. It would be better than declaring you guilty to protect myself from embarrassment."
Eleanor watched the waves below. "That sounds wise on a fine afternoon," she said. "It may feel harder at dawn."
"I am certain it would," Julian answered. "But I know what happens when I behave as I did. I don't want to live that way again."
She studied him for a long time. He did not lean toward her or reach for her hand. At last she said, "Thank you for not asking when I am coming home." He admitted that he had wanted to ask from the moment he saw her. She smiled slightly and said the admission made his restraint easier to believe. They walked back together, drank tea in Beatrice's drawing room, and parted before dinner. Nothing was settled. Yet both felt that something which had remained frozen since autumn had finally begun to move.
After Julian returned to Wrenford, Eleanor spent several days wondering whether she had allowed the meeting to become too pleasant. She had laughed beside him as she once did, and she had wanted to reach across the tea table and brush a crumb from his cuff. Wanting those things frightened her because desire could be mistaken for forgiveness. She was not afraid of loving her husband. She was afraid of returning to a life in which love excused the belief that she could not have a thought or a loyalty beyond his understanding.