That was why Eli’s paper copy still listed Attachment Seven.
The binder Hale threw onto the table was older than the digital version he had altered.
His own contempt had handed Eli the discrepancy.
Eli realized that around lunchtime.
He almost laughed.
Not because anything was funny.
Because if Hale had simply handed him nothing, Eli might not have noticed until much later.
Instead, the prosecutor had made a performance out of humiliating him.
And slammed the clue directly in front of him.
At 12:17, Judge Ellison returned to the bench.
Everyone stood.
She looked exhausted.
Angry.
Controlled.
“The court has received preliminary technical information concerning the electronic filing history.”
She looked toward Hale.
“Mr. Hale will no longer appear as counsel for the state in this matter pending separate review.”
A murmur moved through the gallery.
Hale stared straight ahead.
Judge Ellison continued.
“The district attorney has assigned substitute counsel.”
A woman in her forties rose from the prosecution table.
Assistant District Attorney Monica Reyes.
No smile.
No theatrics.
“Good afternoon, Your Honor.”
“Ms. Reyes, have you reviewed the video?”
“Yes.”
“Have you reviewed the state’s remaining evidence against Mr. Carter?”
“Preliminarily.”
“And?”
Reyes looked toward Eli.
Then back at the judge.
“The state requests a recess until tomorrow morning to complete an urgent review.”
Eli stood.
“Your Honor, I object.”
Reyes looked at him.
Judge Ellison nodded.
“Basis?”
Eli swallowed.
His voice remained steady.
“I was arrested three weeks ago.”
He looked at the prosecution table.
“The state had evidence Friday that its main witness appears to be involved in the crime and that another man is on video loading the stolen goods.”
He held up the binder.
“Then the evidence disappeared last night.”
Nobody moved.
Eli continued.
“I don't think the state needs another day to decide whether it has probable cause to keep prosecuting me.”
Judge Ellison studied him.
That was a much better argument than she expected from a nineteen-year-old.
But she answered carefully.
“Mr. Carter, I understand your position.”
Eli nodded.
“The court also has an obligation to allow substitute counsel enough time to understand a record that has become substantially more complicated this morning.”
Eli's jaw tightened.
Judge Ellison added:
“But I am not leaving your release conditions unchanged.”
She looked at Reyes.
“State object to release on personal recognizance?”
Reyes shook her head.
“No, Your Honor.”
“Travel restriction?”
“No objection to removal.”
“Electronic monitoring?”
“No objection to removal.”
Eli closed his eyes briefly.
For three weeks, he had worn an ankle monitor.
He hated it more than the handcuffs.
Judge Ellison continued.
“Mr. Carter’s bond conditions are modified immediately. He is released on recognizance. Monitoring terminated today.”
Then she looked directly at Eli.
“Tomorrow at nine.”
He nodded.
“Thank you, Your Honor.”
Outside the courtroom, reporters were waiting.
Eli had no idea how they found out so quickly.
He stepped through the courthouse doors and microphones appeared.
“Eli!”
“Mr. Carter, did prosecutors hide evidence?”
“Do you believe Richard Hale should be charged?”
“Will you sue?”
“Who do you think the man in the video is?”
Eli froze.
His mother, Denise, pushed through the crowd.
She hugged him before anyone could stop her.
Eli held on harder than he intended.
She whispered:
“You okay?”
He almost said yes.
Then changed his mind.
“No.”
Denise nodded.
“Good answer.”
They walked away without speaking to reporters.
That evening, the ankle monitor came off.