Her voice was barely above conversational volume.
“Mr. Hale.”
He stood.
“Yes, Your Honor.”
“Your principal witness appears on the video assisting in the theft.”
Hale swallowed.
“That is one interpretation.”
Eli actually turned toward him.
One interpretation?
Judge Ellison’s eyes narrowed.
“What is another?”
Hale said nothing.
The judge continued.
“And the individual your witness identified as Mr. Carter appears to be someone else.”
“We would need enhancement and authentication before making that determination.”
“Did you watch this video before last night?”
Hale paused.
“Yes.”
Eli closed his eyes.
There it was.
The answer.
Judge Ellison did not blink.
“When?”
“Friday.”
“And after watching it, did you provide a copy to Mr. Carter?”
Hale looked toward Eli.
“His prior counsel had received supplemental discovery.”
Eli stood immediately.
“No, Your Honor.”
Hale snapped:
“You don't know everything your counsel received.”
Eli held up the binder.
“This is the package his office transferred to me when he withdrew.”
Judge Ellison looked toward the court-appointed standby attorney seated behind the rail.
“Mr. Lang?”
Attorney Thomas Lang stood.
“I reviewed the transfer inventory this morning, Your Honor. There was no video file corresponding to Attachment Seven.”
Hale’s face tightened.
Judge Ellison turned back.
“Was the file disclosed to defense counsel?”
Hale said:
“It was uploaded.”
“That is not my question.”
Silence.
“Was it provided to defense counsel?”
Hale’s eyes dropped briefly.
“I would need to confirm transmission records.”
Judge Ellison looked toward the clerk.
“Ms. Watkins.”
Linda was already typing.
The judge asked:
“When was Attachment Seven first uploaded?”
“Friday at 4:18 p.m.”
“Mr. Ward withdrew when?”
“Thursday afternoon.”
Judge Ellison stared at Hale.
“So it could not have been part of the discovery supplied to him before withdrawal.”
Hale did not answer.
Eli felt something strange.
Not victory.
Not yet.
Anger.
Cold anger.
For three weeks, he had been called a thief.
Suspended.
Fired.
Handcuffed in his dorm hallway.
His mother had emptied part of her retirement savings to post bond.
All while the state possessed a video showing another man committing the crime with its star witness.
And yesterday, somebody logged into Richard Hale’s account and removed it.
Eli sat back down because he no longer trusted his legs.
Judge Ellison looked toward the prosecution table.
“Mr. Hale, I am ordering you not to access, alter, delete, supplement, or otherwise modify any electronic evidence associated with this matter until further order.”
Hale’s head snapped up.
“Your Honor—”
“I am also directing the clerk to preserve the complete audit history.”
She turned toward the bailiff.
“Contact courthouse IT. I want an administrator in this courtroom.”
Hale stared.
“Judge, this is extraordinary.”
Ellison’s expression did not change.
“Yes.”
She looked at the frozen image of Calvin Ross loading stolen electronics.
“It is.”
The morning hearing was supposed to take forty minutes.
By noon, nobody had reached the original motion.
Court IT arrived at 10:02.
Professional Responsibility counsel from the prosecutor’s office arrived at 10:34.
The elected district attorney arrived twenty minutes later.
Richard Hale stopped speaking except through counsel.
The electronic audit showed that Hale had opened Attachment Seven from his home connection at 10:58 Sunday night.
At 11:41, he initiated an amendment to the supplemental filing.
At 11:43, Attachment Seven was removed.
At 11:46, a new PDF index was uploaded.
But Hale made another mistake.
The new index had not synchronized into the printed binder assembled earlier by his assistant.