PROSECUTOR MOCKED A 19-YEAR-OLD FOR DEFENDING HIMSELF — THEN THE COURT CLERK FOUND THE MISSING ATTACHMENT

Chapter 1

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

The first mistake Prosecutor Richard Hale made was assuming Eli Carter was too young to understand the file.

The second was throwing that file directly in front of him.

At 9:06 on a Monday morning, a thick blue evidence binder slammed onto the defense table inside Courtroom 4B of the Franklin County Courthouse.

BAM.

Several people in the gallery looked up.

Richard Hale smiled.

“Everything the state has against you.”

Across the table, nineteen-year-old Eli Carter calmly moved his coffee out of the way before the binder could knock it over.

Hale remained standing.

Fifty-two years old.

Tall.

Heavyset.

Silver-streaked hair.

Expensive charcoal suit.

Red silk tie.

Twenty-six years as a prosecutor.

He had tried homicides.

Armed robberies.

Fraud cases.

Drug conspiracies.

And now he was looking down at a nineteen-year-old kid wearing a navy suit that cost less than Hale’s shoes.

Eli looked exactly as young as he was.

Slim.

Short neat twists.

Smooth face.

Intelligent brown eyes.

White shirt.

Dark tie.

Polished black shoes.

No legal team.

No private investigator.

No stacks of leather briefcases.

Just Eli.

A yellow legal pad.

Two pens.

And the discovery binder.

Hale glanced toward the gallery, where several younger assistant prosecutors were sitting.

Then back at Eli.

“You’re nineteen and defending yourself?”

He laughed.

“This will be over before lunch.”

Eli did not look up.

He opened the binder.

“Then this should be an easy question.”

Hale’s smile paused.

“What question?”

Eli turned to the first page.

The evidence index.

His finger moved slowly down the list.

Attachment One.

Crime-scene photographs.

Attachment Two.

Arrest report.

Attachment Three.

Witness statement.

Attachment Four.

Store inventory records.

Five.

Six.

Then—

Seven.

Eli stopped.

He flipped through the numbered dividers.

Tab One.

Two.

Three.

Four.

Five.

Six.

Then—

Eight.

He went backward.

Checked again.

Nothing.

Eli lifted the index page.

“Why is Attachment Seven listed here…”

He looked directly at Hale.

“…but missing from your evidence?”

Hale did not answer immediately.

The smile returned.

Smaller this time.

“Probably a clerical numbering issue.”

Eli looked at the index.

“It has a title.”

Hale’s expression changed slightly.

Judge Margaret Ellison looked up from the bench.

“What title?”

Eli stood.

“Your Honor, the state’s own evidence index lists Attachment Seven as ‘North Loading Dock Camera Export, September 14, 9:14 p.m. through 9:31 p.m.’”

The courtroom became quieter.

Hale stepped toward the table.

“Mr. Carter is misunderstanding how supplemental discovery is organized.”

Eli looked at him.

“Then where is it?”

Hale’s jaw tightened.

Judge Ellison turned toward the clerk.

News in the same category

PROSECUTOR MOCKED A 19-YEAR-OLD FOR DEFENDING HIMSELF — THEN THE COURT CLERK FOUND THE MISSING ATTACHMENT

11 Part