“That does not make self-representation advisable.”
“No, ma’am.”
“Then why?”
Eli looked at the prosecution table.
Richard Hale was not there that day.
One of his assistants was.
Eli said:
“Because later is getting closer to trial.”
Judge Ellison allowed the waiver only after a lengthy competency inquiry and appointed standby counsel available if Eli requested help.
But at the defense table, Eli sat alone.
That was exactly how Richard Hale found him Monday morning.
And Hale mistook alone for helpless.
“Ms. Watkins.”
Judge Ellison’s voice brought everyone back to the present.
“Can you determine who removed Attachment Seven?”
The clerk hesitated.
“The audit record should show account activity.”
Hale immediately stepped forward.
“Your Honor, before we go further, I object to characterizing an electronic docket action as evidence of impropriety.”
Judge Ellison looked at him.
“Nobody has characterized it as anything yet.”
Hale stopped.
The judge turned back.
“Check the audit record.”
Linda typed again.
Hale’s face remained controlled.
But Eli noticed his right thumb rubbing against the edge of his index finger.
Over.
And over.
The first visible sign of nervousness Eli had seen.
Linda opened the activity log.
Then looked toward the judge.
“It was removed using a prosecution-office filing credential.”
Hale exhaled.
“Which credential?”
Linda read.
“RHale-17.”
The courtroom went completely silent.
Every person in the room knew those initials.
Richard Hale stared at the screen.
“That cannot be correct.”
Judge Ellison’s voice became dangerously quiet.
“Is that your account?”
“Yes, Your Honor, but—”
“Did you access this case last night?”
Hale hesitated.
“I reviewed materials from home.”
“Did you remove Attachment Seven?”
“No.”
Eli watched.
Hale continued quickly.
“I may have replaced a supplemental filing. The electronic system sometimes reflects version changes as removals.”
Judge Ellison turned toward the clerk.
“Does it?”
Linda answered carefully.
“A replacement filing normally creates a superseding entry. This shows a deletion request followed by removal from the public case packet.”
Hale’s face reddened.
“Public packet?”
“Yes.”
“Is the original retained?”
Linda nodded.
“The court archive should still preserve the uploaded file.”
Eli’s eyes lifted.
Judge Ellison said:
“Restore it.”
Hale stepped forward.
“Your Honor—”
“Mr. Hale.”
He stopped.
The judge stared at him.
“We are not proceeding with another word of today’s evidentiary hearing until I know what Attachment Seven contains.”
No one moved.
Then Judge Ellison added:
“And nobody leaves.”
Restoring the archived file took eleven minutes.
Eli sat down.
For the first time that morning, his hands shook.
Very slightly.
He put them underneath the table.
Across the aisle, Hale whispered urgently to his assistant.
The assistant looked confused.
Then alarmed.
Eli opened his yellow legal pad.
He wrote:
Why remove video?
Below it:
What does it show?
Then:
Who else saw it?
The clerk finally spoke.
“I have it.”
Judge Ellison looked toward the monitor.
“Display it.”
Hale immediately objected.
“Your Honor, without proper authentication—”
“This is not being admitted for the jury.”