A little after five, Patrice persuaded the family to turn up the music for one of Elise's favorite Stevie Wonder songs. The speaker was modest; guests could still hear one another without shouting. Children danced on the grass while a retired teacher argued with Walter about whether the school district had ever served edible fish on Fridays. Walter was midway through a spirited defense of the cafeteria workers when someone called for the birthday cake. He protested, as expected, and allowed himself to be led to the table, as expected. For one brief interval the yard gave him exactly what he had missed for eight years: Elise's friends, his children, his grandchildren, and the uncomplicated luxury of being surrounded by people who remembered him whole.
Graham heard the music through his kitchen window and looked toward the property line. He had been unable to enjoy an afternoon nap; the children had laughed near the fence, and one car had occupied a space he thought ought to remain empty. He considered stepping outside but disliked the idea of another conversation in which Walter smiled and promised to cooperate without surrendering the right to entertain guests. Graham had complained before. This time he wanted somebody with authority to make the gathering stop.
When the emergency dispatcher answered, Graham described the party as large and disorderly. He said people were yelling, omitting the fact that the noise came from a group singing happy birthday. The dispatcher asked whether anyone appeared injured or whether a fight had begun. Graham said he couldn't tell. The conversation might have ended as an ordinary noise complaint if he had not remembered a dark object he had seen near the barbecue. “I think somebody may have a gun,” he said. The dispatcher asked what he had actually seen. Graham hesitated, then told her it was something black in a person's hand.
“Did someone point it at another person?” the dispatcher asked. Graham said no, or perhaps that he hadn't seen it clearly. “Have you heard shots?” Again no. “Can you describe the person holding the object?” Graham looked toward the yard, where three people stood beside the grill. He could not. The dispatcher documented the uncertainty and warned the responding units about a possible firearm. Graham hung up feeling a flicker of satisfaction, which he quickly told himself was relief that responsible people were taking the matter seriously.
Mercer and Fallon were four blocks away when the call arrived. Mercer was twenty-eight, a patrol officer with a reputation for quick arrests and impatience during routine assignments. Fallon was thirty-six, broad-shouldered and more experienced, the kind of officer who had learned that a quiet partner could influence a scene as much as a loud one. They had worked together often enough to finish each other's complaints. Both knew Graham's address, or thought they did. He had summoned police over the Bennett family before, and each visit had ended without serious enforcement.