That pride could be complicated. In recent months Walter had complained that Daniel no longer had conversations without checking his phone. Daniel would come to dinner, sit in the living room, then excuse himself to answer questions about overtime, a training instructor, or a disciplinary review. His wife had left years earlier after a separation both parties handled with more politeness than happiness, and his relationship with his teenage daughter had become a careful negotiation around schedules. Walter understood that leadership was difficult. He did not understand why his son acted as though the department would collapse if he ate a whole plate of chicken without being interrupted.
There had been a minor argument about the birthday before the party was planned. Daniel suggested reserving a restaurant room so nobody would have to clean. Walter said he preferred home, where people could come and go without being charged for water. Daniel offered to pay for catering. Walter asked him to bring a cake and arrive before the candles were lit. “You can afford a cake,” he said. “Time is the expensive part.” Daniel laughed and promised. Walter recognized the distracted sound beneath the promise and wondered whether his son heard the difference.
Patrice took charge of the plans because somebody had to make a stubborn man do what was good for him. She borrowed tables, arranged for their cousins to barbecue, and called old friends from Walter's school days. The neighbor two doors down offered string lights. A former teacher brought a photo album from the school. Walter's granddaughter Tessa, twenty-two and studying to become a social worker, found a bakery willing to decorate the cake in the exact pale lavender her grandmother had always chosen. She bought two large golden candles because seventy smaller flames seemed impractical, and because she wanted the number to appear clearly in the photographs.
Tessa was the first to notice their neighbor Graham Pritchard watching from behind his fence. Graham lived beyond the Bennett property with his wife and had complained for years about cars, music, deliveries, and children playing basketball. Sometimes he had legitimate grievances. Walter remembered moving a borrowed trailer when its tire rested across Graham's driveway, and Patrice remembered asking guests to park elsewhere after a previous cookout. The problem was that Graham had grown accustomed to being angry before he knew what had happened. He treated any gathering as a violation waiting to be written down.
At half past four a cousin's car blocked part of the curb. Graham appeared beside it almost immediately and said the street was becoming a parking lot. The cousin apologized and moved the car. Walter called over the fence to ask whether Graham wanted a plate of food. Graham replied that he wanted the neighborhood kept peaceful. “We've got peace and barbecue,” Walter said. “Take your pick.” The cousin laughed, but Walter didn't. He knew joking did not always soften resentment. When Graham went inside, Walter asked his nephew to make certain every vehicle remained clear of driveways and hydrants.