to review. None of this happened at the birthday table or because Daniel pointed a finger and made a phone call. The careful pace frustrated reporters who expected immediate consequences and relatives who wanted the pain answered quickly. Price reminded Walter that decisions made too hastily could be overturned and would leave the family with another conflict to endure.
Fallon's hearing included footage of the moment he struck the cake. His attorney emphasized the possible-weapon warning and the difficulty of judging split-second decisions afterward. The hearing officer acknowledged the danger of retrospective certainty, then asked what information Fallon had gained by destroying the cake. Fallon said he was moving objects to check the table. The video showed he did not continue a systematic search; he looked at Walter and announced that the party was over. The hearing officer found that the explanation was not credible in light of his movements and words. The dismissal was sustained after the department's appeal process concluded.
Mercer's case turned on the shove and the report he wrote afterward. He maintained he had perceived a threat, but could not identify facts that reasonably supported immediate physical force against Walter. His representative argued that the fall caused no fracture and that Mercer had little time to choose. The hearing officer rejected the idea that injury severity determined whether force had been justified. Walter's age and the patio step made the risk particularly serious, but the central issue was whether the shove was warranted at all. The department's decision to terminate Mercer was eventually sustained.
Criminal review proceeded under a different standard. Prosecutors charged Fallon with a misdemeanor property offense after reviewing the video and interviews. Fallon resolved the case through a no-contest plea with restitution and related conditions. Mercer faced a misdemeanor battery charge that ended in a negotiated lesser offense with probation and community service. Some residents thought both outcomes were too light; others said the men had already lost their careers. Walter did not pretend the penalties satisfied every feeling he carried. He did, however, appreciate that the processes had required evidence rather than deference to Daniel's rank.
A department commander proposed that the city emphasize how quickly leadership had acted once the incident became public. Daniel objected. The department had moved appropriately to preserve evidence and request outside review, he said, but it had failed to respond adequately to earlier signs of trouble. A press release praising its own courage without acknowledging that history would turn necessary accountability into congratulation. The commander warned that public confidence could be damaged by admitting too much. Daniel replied that confidence built on incomplete information was not the kind worth protecting.