“Sir, stay back,” Mercer said. The man kept his hands visible and looked once around the yard, counting people and noticing where the officers stood. “You pushed my father,” he said quietly. “And somebody destroyed his birthday cake.” Fallon turned from the table, irritated to have another person demanding an explanation. Mercer took a step forward, moving his hand toward his belt. Neither officer yet knew they were confronting Daniel Bennett, the assistant chief responsible for policy, training, and professional standards in their own police department. Daniel did not tell them immediately. First he wanted an answer to a simpler question: why was his father lying in the grass?
Two hours earlier, Walter had been irritated by the birthday party for reasons he claimed were financial. He stood at his kitchen counter, examining the foil-wrapped trays Patrice had brought, and announced that there was enough food to feed a fire station. Patrice, who was fifty and had learned over several decades that her father's objections were not always requests for change, continued arranging sandwiches without looking up. “You said you wanted a quiet afternoon,” she said. “I did. I wanted quiet right up until you rented every chair in the county.” Patrice pointed toward the backyard, where neighbors were helping hang the banner between two poles. “Those chairs belong to the church. They cost nothing. Stop pretending you don't know half the people outside.”
Walter was a thin man with broad hands and a habit of squinting over his glasses rather than putting them on. His hair had turned silver all at once during the last years of his marriage, and he kept it clipped close because his wife had always said he looked respectable that way. His late wife Elise had loved birthday parties, especially the kind where guests brought dishes wrapped in dish towels and people argued cheerfully over who had made the better potato salad. Walter preferred anniversaries quietly acknowledged over breakfast, but he had never denied her the pleasure. Eight years after she died, a crowded yard could still remind him of her so suddenly that he sometimes needed an excuse to step indoors.
Patrice noticed when his attention drifted toward the framed photograph on the sideboard. Her mother wore a green dress in it and had one hand on Walter's shoulder, laughing at something beyond the camera. “She would've insisted on more flowers,” Patrice said. Walter considered the elaborate lavender arrangement beside the photograph and shook his head. “She would've complained that these were the wrong shade, then made everybody admire them anyway.” They shared a smile. He reached over and straightened the frame by a fraction of an inch before going outside to greet the guests he had insisted he didn't want.
Walter had spent thirty-five years as secretary to an elementary-school principal in the old north district. People who knew nothing about school offices sometimes imagined his job had consisted of answering telephones and sorting papers. His children knew better. He could tell by the sound of a child entering the office