not promise to prove a dramatic high-speed chase through the neighborhood, and she did not charge Andrew with felony fleeing. Andrew listened carefully, noting the difference between the story that had led to the gunpoint encounter and the narrower charge before the jury. The difference relieved him and disturbed him. If the alleged flight was no longer the issue, why had it carried so much force in the alley?
Caroline's opening was equally measured. She told jurors that an improper turn and criminal recklessness were not the same allegation, and that the prosecution would have to prove the latter beyond a reasonable doubt. She said the evidence would show that an officer had formed a strong impression, then described events in a way the recordings did not support. She would ask jurors to look at the road rather than the seriousness of the accusation. Andrew noticed she did not call Rourke a liar. She had once explained to him that a person could be sincerely mistaken, careless with memory, or intentionally misleading, and the defense did not need to prove which explanation was correct to challenge an unsupported charge.
Rourke was the prosecution's principal witness. He entered in uniform, sat straight in the witness chair, and answered the preliminary questions with the ease of someone who had testified before. He described the busy intersection and Andrew's movement around other vehicles. He said the Tesla accelerated hard and seemed to swing sideways as it entered the road. He recalled turning on his emergency equipment, attempting to catch up, and watching the vehicle disappear into the townhouse neighborhood. When asked why he approached the garage with his weapon drawn, he referred to the possibility that a driver who appeared to flee might retrieve a weapon inside a residence.
Andrew felt his stomach tighten. He wanted to stand and tell the courtroom that the officer had not been behind him, that he had never heard the siren until he was home, and that he had stepped from the garage because he thought a neighbor needed help. Caroline wrote a short note and passed it to him: Stay with the evidence. He read the words twice. Rourke's confidence did not change the position of his cruiser on the rear camera. The witness was entitled to explain his impression. The defense would be entitled to test it.
On cross-examination, Caroline asked Rourke to identify precisely where he had been stopped when the Tesla passed. He marked a diagram. She asked which direction he faced and whether a U-turn had been necessary before following Andrew. He acknowledged that it had. She asked whether he had a dashboard camera recording the initial maneuver. He said no. She asked whether he could provide a speed measurement from radar or another calibrated instrument. He said the estimate came from training and experience. Caroline did not argue that visual estimates were meaningless; she asked what distance and duration supported this particular estimate.
Rourke described the rear of the Tesla lifting slightly and moving sideways. Caroline asked whether he had recorded that description immediately or later in his report. He said he had observed it and described it on his body camera. She asked how long he had maintained an unobstructed view after turning