"You weren't punished for buying breakfast," she said. "You got frightened while doing something you were supposed to be able to do safely. I don't want the story to become funny just because the facts are absurd." Andrew agreed. He folded the bag carefully and placed it back with the other things, understanding that his wife had kept a record of the day in a language different from his camera files.
They drove to court before sunrise. Caroline had advised Andrew to dress as he normally would for a professional meeting, not to present himself as a character in a performance of innocence. He wore dark trousers, a light shirt, and the wedding band he always wore. Emily chose a seat behind the defense table and brought a small notebook. The courtroom had high windows, pale walls, and a sound system that made each cough seem public. Andrew watched the clerk arrange folders while prospective jurors entered carrying work bags and paperback books. He wondered how many had taken time off from jobs and families to decide whether one ordinary turn had been reckless.
Judge Elaine Porter entered shortly after nine. She was direct and economical with words, the kind of judge who did not permit lawyers to turn scheduling disagreements into speeches. She explained the charge and the standard of proof, then asked jurors about experiences that might affect impartiality. A woman described serving on a neighborhood safety committee. A man said his brother was a police officer. Another juror had been unfairly ticketed years earlier and admitted he still resented it. Judge Porter did not assume any of those facts automatically settled a person's suitability. She asked follow-up questions until each juror had explained whether they could evaluate testimony and video without deciding from a job title alone.
Andrew found the process exhausting. Every answer reminded him that strangers carried experiences he knew nothing about, and that their decision would be shaped by how they understood evidence through those experiences. One juror said she tended to trust police because they made difficult decisions under pressure. Another answered that uniformed witnesses deserved neither more nor less credibility than anyone else. Caroline watched carefully, looking for people willing to distinguish a witness's confidence from accuracy. By late morning the jury was seated. Andrew wanted to know what they thought of him already, then recognized that none had yet heard the facts.
The prosecution's opening statement was restrained compared with the officer's roadside anger. Laura Benton described a busy intersection, a driver who lost patience, and a maneuver she argued showed disregard for safety. She referred to Rourke's observations and the risks present when a vehicle moves rapidly around stopped traffic. She did