At supper that evening, Lucy asked whether the judge had made everything better. Andrew told her the judge was still waiting for people to finish gathering information. She considered that answer seriously. "Like when Mrs. Weller says we have to hear both sides before deciding who broke a crayon?" she asked. Andrew smiled despite himself. "Something like that," he said. He did not explain that the justice system could take months to hear what a seven-year-old teacher could resolve in a classroom. He promised Lucy that whatever happened, he and Emily would tell her the truth about it.
A week later, Andrew found himself sitting in the garage after midnight. The door was closed, the car silent, and the concrete smelled of the rubber mats he had recently washed. He tried to remember the exact position of Rourke's pistol and could not decide whether it had been held in one hand or two. Certain details were as sharp as the sound of his own voice saying for what. Others blurred each time he returned to them. He wrote down what he remembered before the memories changed further. Caroline had asked him not to rehearse his testimony obsessively, but to preserve honest notes with the dates on which they were written. He followed that instruction and placed the notebook with the camera drives.
Walter Lowell saw the garage light beneath Andrew's door and knocked gently. Walter was seventy-six, a former school-bus driver who lived with his wife in the adjoining row of homes. He had been in his kitchen when the sirens arrived and had seen several police vehicles filling the alley. "I didn't want to put my nose into it," he said, "but you looked like a man who needed somebody to know he was there." Andrew invited him inside. Walter sat on a folding chair and listened as Andrew explained the citations, the footage, and the legal delay. He asked whether the children had been present. Andrew said no. Walter stared at the garage wall. "That's the part you keep going back to, isn't it?"
Walter told him about a school bus accident from thirty years earlier. Another driver had run a stop sign and struck the bus near the rear wheel. Nobody had been seriously injured, but Walter had spent months hearing the scrape of metal whenever he approached an intersection. He had wanted somebody to give him a certificate proving that he had not been careless. The investigation eventually found he had followed procedure, yet the sound remained. "The facts matter," Walter said. "They just don't always cure the thing in your body that got frightened." Andrew had not known Walter was capable of speaking so plainly about fear. He found comfort in having it treated as ordinary, not as a weakness that required apology.
After Walter left, Andrew wrote one more sentence in his notebook. He had been concentrating on proving that the officer was never close enough to give a recognizable command. He also wanted to prove that a frightened person could tell the truth about his experience even when he did not behave like someone in a courtroom drama. The two goals were related, but they were not identical. His case might end when a judge ruled on the driving. The second task would require him to learn how to live in his own neighborhood again.