Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

Chapter 8

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

That principle felt different when someone had just stepped on his wallet.

On his fourth request to speak with counsel, Dugan returned carrying a clipboard. He began filling a form with deliberate slowness, pausing whenever Anthony spoke. The officer wrote that the detainee had "declined to provide reliable identifying information" and had "made statements about working for the government." Anthony asked him to preserve the body-camera footage in its entirety. Dugan glanced up.

"You can quit trying to sound like a lawyer."

"I am asking you to preserve evidence," Anthony said. "I am also telling you that the statements you are writing are inaccurate. I identified myself at the scene, and your partner removed my identification."

"Every guy we bring in says something."

"Then you ought to be especially good at checking."

Dugan closed the clipboard hard. "You think you're smarter than everybody in the room."

Anthony looked at him for a long moment. "I think you're refusing to find out whether I'm telling the truth."

In the lobby, Marjorie had settled into a chair near the front desk. She had not been asked to remain; she had volunteered to provide a statement, then discovered that being at the station made her livestream seem more authoritative. Her viewership was climbing because a local neighborhood page had shared the video. Comments divided into angry camps. Some praised her. Others asked why the officers had never looked at the man's documents. A few wondered aloud whether the man was an actual homeowner. Marjorie replied that she had lived on the street for twenty-three years and would certainly know if someone like him had purchased property there.

She did not recognize the contradiction. There had been a real-estate sign on Fourteen Maplewood Ridge until three weeks earlier. A moving truck was in the driveway. The man she accused had carried boxes toward the front door using a key. He had told her his name and his claim of ownership. None of that fit a typical burglary, but she had chosen a different explanation and repeated it often enough to hear it as fact.

Paul Kessler called to congratulate her on taking action. He said the neighborhood had grown too permissive and the board ought to discuss additional security patrols. Helen Brooks, the association treasurer, called too, but her tone was very different. "Marjorie, have you checked the sale records?"

"The police are handling it."

"The county records are public. I looked after seeing your video. Fourteen was sold to an Anthony Reed last week."

Marjorie sat upright. "People can put false names on documents."

"Not usually on a recorded deed," Helen replied. "You need to stop filming and let the facts come out."

Marjorie hung up. Helen's voice sounded accusatory, and Marjorie was not ready to acknowledge the possibility that the accusation belonged in the other direction. She replayed her own video and watched the moment when Dugan pressed Anthony into the grass. The number of viewers increased again. She told herself that so many people could not possibly be interested in a mistake.

News in the same category

Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

50 Part