Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

Chapter 10

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Eleanor understood. She had worked with him on public-corruption cases in which one careless accusation could damage a year of careful investigation. She would notify the appropriate people, preserve relevant office communications, and wait for the attorney before making a public statement. After the call she walked into the conference room of the United States Attorney's Office, where a half-dozen lawyers were reviewing evidence in a contracting fraud matter, and told them their boss would not be attending the afternoon meeting. The ordinary work of government continued, but not one person in that room forgot the expression on her face.

Ward arrived at the station as Anthony finished the call. She asked for the incident file at the desk and read the name on the intake sheet. Anthony Reed. She had seen that name on correspondence concerning a regional racketeering investigation and remembered meeting him briefly during an interagency briefing. He had asked pointed questions about witness protection and criticized the tendency to treat local complaints as distractions from larger cases. Ward was less surprised by his position than by the speed with which he had been detained without identification.

She went directly to the interview room. Anthony stood when she entered, then seemed to think better of the formality and sat again. His shirt was grass-stained and his wrists red. Ward noticed both without needing him to point them out.

"Mr. Reed, I'm Captain Denise Ward. Do you need medical attention?"

"I'd like my wrists examined and documented," he answered. "I also want access to the incident report and an opportunity for my lawyer to review the legal basis for detention."

"We'll arrange the medical assessment. I understand you say you own the property."

"I do. My attorney is bringing the recorded deed. The documents are also in a box at the house. The officers declined to examine them."

Ward closed her eyes briefly. "I need to apologize that this has taken so long to establish. But I'm not going to ask you to accept an apology as a substitute for an investigation."

He had not expected that sentence. "Thank you," he said. "That distinction matters."

Ward stepped into the corridor and called Dugan and Nash into her office. The exchange was controlled at first. She asked them to describe what they had observed before reaching the address, what evidence of an unlawful entry they had seen, and why they had not checked the deed or called the property owner. Dugan insisted that the suspect had behaved evasively. Ward asked him what, precisely, the behavior had been.

"He reached into his pocket," Dugan said. "He could have had anything."

"Did you instruct him not to reach?"

"Yes, ma'am."

"Before or after he told you he was reaching for a house key?"

Dugan paused. Nash looked down. Ward asked the younger officer directly what Anthony had said. Nash described the man's calm introduction and his offer to show the key. The more accurately he spoke, the angrier Dugan became. Ward stopped them before they began arguing.

"You will preserve the video from both cameras and your vehicle cameras," she said. "You will not discuss the incident with each other until you have prepared separate statements. The evidence room will secure the footage. Neither of you will return to that address while this matter is reviewed."

Dugan stared at her. "Over a misunderstanding?"

News in the same category

Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

50 Part