Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

Chapter 7

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

At the station Nash offered to loosen the cuffs when Anthony mentioned pain in his wrists. Dugan answered before he could move. "He can wait."

The younger officer looked at Anthony in the rearview mirror. His eyes flickered away. Anthony wondered whether the man had ever been taught that obedience to a colleague was not the same as loyalty to the law. He remembered junior prosecutors entering his office with the same conflict on their faces, wanting to challenge a senior attorney but afraid of what it would cost them. The resemblance made him angry. Nash had taken an oath that was not contingent on his partner's approval.

At intake a desk sergeant asked for Anthony's full name, date of birth, and address. Dugan interrupted twice, insisting that the prisoner had been uncooperative at the scene. Anthony answered clearly anyway. He gave his name and the address on Maplewood Ridge, then explained that his driver's license had not yet been updated because he had closed on the property only the previous week. He asked them to contact the title company or examine the deed in his moving paperwork. The desk sergeant typed a short note into the system and moved on to the next step. Anthony could see the name he had given appearing on the screen, which made Dugan's original refusal seem more senseless by the minute.

His fingerprints were taken despite his repeated request for clarification of the charge. He was photographed. He asked for counsel and a telephone, and the desk sergeant told him he would have the opportunity to make the appropriate calls after processing. He did not claim a constitutional right to a telephone call that the Constitution itself did not plainly promise on demand. He knew that access depended on detention procedures and state rules, and he did not want to give anyone a convenient reason to dismiss his other complaints as legal bluster. He simply asked that the time of his request be recorded.

They placed him in an interview room with beige walls and a metal table. Someone had scratched a small star into the corner nearest the door. Anthony sat with his hands flat before him and studied the marks around his wrists. The metal had cut no skin, but a darkening line followed the bones. He turned his left hand and felt a sharp discomfort near the thumb. It was a modest injury compared with those he had encountered in court. That did not make it imaginary, and he resolved not to minimize it merely because he had escaped something worse.

He thought of the oath he had taken upon becoming United States Attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia. The office was responsible for federal prosecutions and civil matters across a complicated region of ports, government contractors, military installations, technology companies, and suburban communities. No single federal prosecutor controlled local police officers or inherited authority over every neighborhood dispute. Anthony had been careful to explain that distinction when friends joked that he now owned the law. He answered to the Department of Justice, to courts, to law, and ultimately to the public. His office was powerful, but he was not supposed to use that power to settle a personal score.

News in the same category

Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

50 Part