Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

Chapter 15

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

right to disrespect someone without a title, then his title was merely a shield available to a privileged few. He wanted the review to address what the officers had done before they knew who he was. Otherwise the lesson would become a warning to check for important people rather than a reason to treat everyone with dignity.

Camille arrived after breakfast with a copy of the station records received through a routine request and a list of preservation notices. She had also spoken with an independent civil-rights attorney, Malik Spencer, who handled claims against public agencies. Anthony knew Malik from legal circles but had never needed him as counsel. Their first conversation was awkward. Anthony was accustomed to being the lawyer who asked difficult questions. Now Malik sat at his kitchen table, listened patiently, and explained why Anthony's instinct to control the investigation might complicate it.

"You are a witness," Malik said. "You are also a complainant and may be a plaintiff. You cannot be the investigator, prosecutor, and judge in your own matter."

"I'm aware."

"Being aware and behaving accordingly are different skills."

Camille hid a smile. Anthony looked at Malik and, for the first time since the incident, felt a small willingness to laugh.

They made a practical plan. Medical photographs of the wrists would be taken that day. Camille would handle the damage to the photograph, boxes, and other property as part of an inventory. Malik would request the dispatch audio, body-camera recordings, use-of-force documentation, detention logs, and any communications between the HOA and police officials. They would ask that a neutral agency review the event if the city police department's internal process appeared compromised. Anthony would not use his office to pursue personal remedies, and his deputy would handle decisions about recusal from any matter that overlapped with the police department. The process was less satisfying than a dramatic phone call to Washington. It was also less likely to collapse under scrutiny.

At noon Captain Ward called Anthony directly. She reported that Dugan and Nash had been placed on administrative duty pending separate interviews. The department would seek all available recordings, including footage from nearby homes. She asked whether he would provide a formal statement with counsel present. Anthony agreed. Before hanging up, Ward added that she had reviewed the initial call and believed the dispatch notes might not accurately reflect the uncertainty of the caller's account.

"What does that mean?" Anthony asked.

"It means there were several points where somebody could have slowed down and checked. I'm not satisfied that anybody did."

After the call Anthony stood by his front window. Across the street Robert Finch stepped onto his porch and looked toward the Reed house. For a moment their eyes met. Robert lifted one hand, hesitant and uncertain. Anthony did not return the wave. He was not ready to interpret a small gesture as an answer to several hours of silence. Robert lowered his hand and went inside. The unfinished exchange would return to both men more often than either expected.

News in the same category

Police Handcuffed a Black Man on His Own Lawn — Then a Captain Read His Name

50 Part