Karen Called 911 on Five Men Relaxing in Their Own Backyard — Then the Sergeant Said, “Chief Carter?”

Chapter 7

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

"This is Chief Nathaniel Brooks," Malcolm said quietly. "He commands our district."

Valerie laughed. "Oh, that's a convenient story."

"It's the truth," Malcolm replied.

Leon stood beside the grill. "Captain Leon Price, patrol division." Curtis rose from his chair with a slow, careful motion. "Lieutenant Curtis Hale, financial investigations." Michael raised his phone slightly. "Detective Michael Grant." Harold lifted his bottle in a weary imitation of a toast. "And I'm Harold Whitcomb. Retired detective. I have the knees to prove it."

The contrast was nearly unbearable. Minutes earlier, Tyler had treated the men as a potential danger whose questions were evidence of defiance. Now the young officer looked at the ground, his whole posture reshaped by the titles he had heard. Nathaniel watched him, and a hard thought settled in his chest. Respect offered only to rank was not respect at all. It was fear of consequences.

"I didn't recognize you, Chief," Jonah said.

Nathaniel nodded. "You didn't need to. You needed to recognize five people sitting peacefully on private property, and you needed to evaluate the evidence before treating them as suspects."

"We received a call," Tyler began.

"Yes, you did. A call required a response. It did not relieve you of the responsibility to investigate."

Valerie stepped toward them. "They're drinking. This is a family neighborhood. I shouldn't have to listen to a mob of men acting like they own the place."

"They are in a private backyard," Malcolm answered. "Please wait outside the gate while I collect statements."

"No," she said. "I want them arrested."

Nathaniel stood and looked at the gate. "I have asked you to leave my property more than once. That request still stands."

For an instant, Valerie looked ready to retreat. Then she noticed Nathaniel's friends watching and seemed to interpret their attention as another humiliation. "You don't get to tell me what to do," she said. "I'll stay where I like."

Malcolm asked her again to move outside. She pointed her camera at him and announced that the whole police department was corrupt. He told her that recording from a lawful public location was not, by itself, a problem, but remaining on property after repeated requests to leave could be. Nathaniel wondered whether that distinction had ever been explained with equal patience to the men in his backyard. He did not say it yet. He wanted Malcolm to finish his work without interference.

"There are recordings," Nathaniel said. "One of my cameras includes audio. We need to preserve the originals, and everyone needs to give an independent account before watching them."

Malcolm looked relieved. "Agreed. I'll contact another supervisor, and we can arrange evidence collection. Given your involvement, Chief, I'd prefer that an outside investigator take over the review."

"So would I."

News in the same category

Karen Called 911 on Five Men Relaxing in Their Own Backyard — Then the Sergeant Said, “Chief Carter?”

50 Part