They all agreed, though not without hesitation. Leon's daughter had recently applied for a job in the department. Curtis had an unresolved grievance against a former colleague that could make his testimony seem partisan. Michael had been involved in a controversial arrest years earlier that was settled without a misconduct finding, but the old allegation might resurface. Harold had retired partly because he no longer trusted how quickly officers were expected to respond to crises they scarcely understood. Each man had a reason to stay silent. Each also knew what would happen if the public learned that the department treated a chief fairly only after his rank became known.
"We do it the right way," Harold said. "No shortcuts. No speeches about what everybody must think. Just what happened."
Nathaniel agreed. He had spent too many years watching anger become an excuse to neglect evidence. The facts were strong enough to stand without embellishment. Whether the institution would face them was another question.
The independent investigator assigned to the complaint was Captain Rebecca Sullivan from a neighboring county. She had spent nineteen years in policing and the last six reviewing uses of force and allegations of biased enforcement. Her first rule was that an investigation belonged neither to the person accused nor to the person making the accusation. She explained it to Nathaniel in a conference room that smelled of stale coffee and floor cleaner, then asked him to describe the afternoon without reference to his own position. It was an unfamiliar request, and Nathaniel realized how often his rank had become part of every conversation he entered.
He began with the corn. He described the yard, the chairs, the music, Valerie looking through the fence, and the gate opening. Rebecca interrupted only when a time or a gesture needed clarification. When Nathaniel described Tyler ordering everyone to stand, she asked what his own hands were doing. When he recalled Jonah moving toward Curtis, she asked whether any officer had actually touched him. When he described Tyler looking toward the house, she asked whether the officer had requested consent to search. Her questions were precise enough to make Nathaniel uncomfortable, which he regarded as a good sign.
"I don't want you to assume anything because of who I am," he told her.
"I don't," she replied. "I also won't ignore the possibility that the officers changed their conduct when they learned your position. That is part of what we must examine."
Rebecca interviewed Leon, Curtis, Michael, and Harold separately. She asked each man to draw the patio and mark where the officers had stood. Their recollections differed on small details. Leon thought Tyler had stepped through the gate before requesting identification. Michael recalled that he entered afterward. Harold could not remember whether Valerie first called Nathaniel a tenant or said he probably rented. These variations did not undermine the central account. They demonstrated that memory was imperfect, and Rebecca included the differences rather than smoothing them out.