Nathaniel knew the woman by sight. Her name was Valerie Pruitt, and she rented a weathered mobile home on the adjoining lot behind the property line. Valerie was in her late forties, with blond hair bleached nearly white, a loud voice, and a talent for turning minor inconveniences into public grievances. Nathaniel had watched her argue with a parcel delivery driver about where he parked, complain to the city when a child dropped chalk dust onto a sidewalk, and threaten to sue a man whose dog crossed the street without a leash. They had exchanged perhaps six conversations in three years. None had been pleasant.
"We live here," Nathaniel replied, setting the corn on the patio table.
Valerie's eyes moved over the chairs. "All five of you?"
"One of us does," Harold answered. "The rest were invited."
She pulled back from the fence. There was a second of silence, and Nathaniel assumed the conversation had ended. Then the side gate scraped open. Valerie stepped through it without a knock, gripping her phone in a hand decorated with chipped red polish. She was wearing patterned shorts and a sleeveless shirt. Her shoes left pale impressions in the narrow strip of dirt beside the patio.
"I need to know who owns this house," she said.
Nathaniel felt the familiar pressure behind his eyes. "I do. You need to step back outside."
She looked at him, then at the house, and laughed. "You expect me to believe that?"
Nobody spoke for a moment. A lawn mower droned somewhere three streets away. Leon's mouth opened and shut, and Michael slowly put down his cup. Nathaniel had heard variations of this question for much of his life: in offices where he had been mistaken for custodial staff, in upscale stores where workers followed him between aisles, at professional events where strangers asked which elected official had invited him. He had once thought that achieving a sufficiently visible position would end the questions. The older he became, the more he understood that prejudice had very little interest in his achievements.
"I've held the deed since my daughter was in kindergarten," he said. "Please leave through the gate."
Valerie did not move. "People around here are concerned about groups gathering and drinking in broad daylight."
"Then the people concerned can have a conversation with me," Nathaniel said. "You are still standing in my yard without permission."
"You're being aggressive."
"No," Curtis answered. "He is being clear."
Valerie swung the camera toward Curtis. "There. Right there. You're threatening a woman."
"He didn't get out of his chair," Michael said.
"I can see what is happening," Valerie snapped. "And the police will see it too."
Nathaniel had no way to know, as she marched back toward the gate, that the next forty minutes would become the most closely examined minutes of his career. The irony was that his closest friends were sitting within a dozen feet of him, men who knew his flaws as well