Cop Tased a Homeowner Inside His Own House — Then the Sergeant Asked What He Did for a Living

Chapter 39

Theme:
Font Size:
24px

Price had not intended to endanger residents. He had wanted to solve a personnel problem without destroying a man's career. Nathaniel knew the impulse well. He had occasionally reassigned deputies who struggled with community complaints, hoping a new environment would help. Sometimes it did. Sometimes the same problems followed. In court papers, Audrey described the department's repeated choice to treat warnings as isolated supervisory issues rather than evidence to be tracked across assignments. Nathaniel read the allegation with a complicated feeling. The words were true, and he wondered how often he had been close to making the same mistake.

The city lawyers disputed that the department's practices had caused Voss to act as he did. They argued that individual officer misconduct could occur despite reasonable training and that the city had policies against unlawful entry and force. Audrey agreed the policies existed. She argued that written prohibitions were not enough if a department repeatedly failed to respond when officers violated them. Both sides retained experts. Those experts disagreed on legal standards, training adequacy, the meaning of earlier complaints, and whether specific omissions could be tied to Nathaniel's injuries. The case became less like a simple replay of the doorbell video and more like an examination of institutional choices.

Nathaniel attended his own deposition in a navy jacket Denise had bought him years earlier. He sat across from the city's attorney while a court reporter recorded the proceedings. The lawyer asked about his career, his knowledge of police contacts, and whether he had ever refused an officer's request before that day. Nathaniel answered carefully. When the lawyer suggested that stepping outside might have prevented the incident, Nathaniel paused. 'Perhaps it would have,' he said. 'But the law doesn't make a person responsible for another person's unlawful use of force because he declined a request he was entitled to decline.' Audrey did not interrupt. The answer stood on its own.

The lawyer also asked whether Nathaniel had experienced discrimination in his own career and whether his distrust of officers influenced his behavior. Nathaniel said he had encountered bias both in uniform and out of it. He had sometimes chosen to avoid confrontation when off duty, and he had sometimes made complaints when he believed officers crossed a line. 'On my porch,' he said, 'I was not trying to win an argument. I was trying to find out why an armed stranger wanted me to leave my house.' He described how Denise had stood behind him and how his attention had been divided between the officer and keeping her safe. When the questions turned to the moment of the shock, he asked for a short break. He was given one.

In the hallway afterward, Audrey said his testimony had been clear. Nathaniel was less interested in praise than in whether he had contradicted himself. She assured him the transcript would be reviewed. He admitted he had forgotten the precise wording of one sentence. Audrey said memory was not a recording and that acknowledging uncertainty was better than pretending. They walked toward the elevators, and Nathaniel suddenly felt exhausted. He had testified in court dozens of times as a deputy. This was different. For once he could not separate his profession from his vulnerability.

News in the same category

Cop Tased a Homeowner Inside His Own House — Then the Sergeant Asked What He Did for a Living

50 Part