'When did we become people who eat dinner on the floor?' Denise asked. 'When we got a house with no furniture.' 'You promised to build me a bench.' 'I did.' 'You still going to?' Nathaniel considered the question. A week earlier he would have said he could not. Now he said, 'Yes. Just not all at once.' Denise leaned against him, careful of his shoulder, and they looked at their new room as if it were another small piece of the life they had almost lost.
The city offered its first settlement in December. Audrey Lane brought the proposal to the Cross house rather than asking them to come downtown. The number was significant, more than Nathaniel and Denise had ever held in one account. It came with a confidentiality clause, a statement that the city admitted no wrongdoing, and a provision requiring them to stop discussing the event publicly. Audrey placed the pages on the kitchen table and let them read. Denise reached the confidentiality language first and pushed the document away. Nathaniel kept reading until the end.
'If we say no, what happens?' he asked. Audrey said they would continue investigating and prepare for depositions, discovery disputes, and perhaps trial. They might receive a better result, a worse one, or none at all. 'A settlement is not just a verdict in miniature,' she said. 'It's an agreement about risk. The city wants certainty. You have to decide what you need in return.' Nathaniel looked at the amount again, then at Denise. 'I need them to change something,' he said. Denise corrected him gently. 'We need them to prove they changed something.'
Audrey prepared a response proposing several nonfinancial terms. The city would review supervisory procedures, preserve complaint records consistently, repair the warning system, conduct independent audits, and publish findings in a form residents could understand. Nathaniel also requested a community advisory process that did not depend on the police chief personally choosing the people allowed to participate. Audrey cautioned that a civil settlement could not automatically create a powerful oversight board if state law or city charter provisions reserved that authority to elected officials. They could secure commitments to seek legislative action and require independent monitoring of changes within the city's existing authority. Nathaniel accepted the distinction. He wanted a reform that could survive a change of mayor, not a promise impressive only during a press conference.
Voss's lawyer asked to meet with the city attorneys about whether the municipality would pay for his defense and indemnify any judgment. The negotiations became tense. His conduct had occurred while wearing a uniform and claiming police authority, but the city disputed whether all aspects of his behavior fell within authorized duties. Voss believed the department owed him complete protection because he had been assigned to patrol that day. His lawyer warned that the law was not as simple as loyalty. State rules, insurance provisions, and findings of intentional misconduct could alter who paid which parts of a judgment.