Winter brought the first holiday season without Sarah. Eli dreaded it before he could explain why. Christmas had always meant his mother singing off-key while untangling lights, and now even a song from a grocery store speaker could send him into sudden tears. Maria suggested they keep some old traditions and change others. Eli chose to make paper snowflakes for the windows but refused to hang the red stockings Sarah had sewn. Maria folded them into a box where he could find them later.
Matthew invited Eli and Maria to his house for Christmas Eve, but told them the gathering could be small. The Brotherhood was organizing a larger meal the next day, and he did not want the boy overwhelmed by twelve adults trying to make the holiday special. They made grilled cheese sandwiches and watched an old animated movie. Eli asked whether they could leave an empty chair at the table for Sarah. Matthew and Maria agreed without asking him to justify it. The chair remained empty, but the meal was not silent.
After dinner Matthew gave Eli a small wooden star he had made in the shop. It was crooked, deliberately so, with smooth edges and a blue ribbon. "For our pancake experiments," he said. Eli laughed and hung it on the window handle. Then he gave Matthew a card from school. Inside he had drawn a man beside a motorcycle and a smaller boy holding a birdhouse. The caption read, Thank you for coming back when I wake up scared. Matthew stared at the words long enough that Eli asked whether he spelled something wrong.
"No," Matthew said. "You got every important word right."
The Brotherhood's Christmas meal was noisy but gentle. Jack arranged a quiet room where Eli could retreat if he needed to, and nobody forced him to sit for group photographs. Aaron brought a puzzle, Ben cooked too much food, and Daniel Pierce helped Eli operate the small magnet robot under a table. Maria stayed close but allowed the boy to make his own way through the afternoon. Near sunset Eli asked if they could visit Sarah's grave. Matthew took him and waited while he placed the wooden star beside the stone for a few minutes before bringing it home again.
"She would have liked everybody," Eli said.
"I think so," Matthew answered.
"Except the loudest ones."
"Especially the loudest ones. She was good at telling them when to be quiet."
Eli smiled. For one moment he looked like a child remembering a funny person rather than a child carrying tragedy. Matthew held on to the memory without trying to freeze it.
The homicide case went to trial after the new year. Prosecutors and defense counsel completed jury selection, and the court established procedures to protect Eli from unnecessary exposure. A specialist prepared him for the possibility of giving evidence, explaining that questions might be difficult and that he could request a pause. The judge ruled that testimony would be taken through an authorized method appropriate to the child's age and the governing law, subject to defense rights. Eli practiced telling ordinary stories in chronological order and distinguishing what he remembered clearly from what he did not. Nobody rehearsed a script about Sarah's death.