Jack found it one evening at the machine shop and looked through only after asking permission. "Looks like a maintenance log," he said.
"That's how my brain works."
"Good. Just remember a child isn't an engine. Some days you do everything right and the noise still comes back."
Matthew closed the notebook thoughtfully. "You've never been a father."
"No," Jack said. "But I've loved enough stubborn people to know you can't repair them by tightening something."
The first trip Eli took with Matthew outside the family services office was to a public park on a Saturday morning. Maria drove him, and a caseworker met them for the first part of the visit. Matthew brought a ball because he knew Eli had once played soccer. The boy ignored it and went straight to the duck pond, where he spent ten minutes explaining that ducks were meaner than they looked. Matthew listened without trying to steer him toward more meaningful conversation.
They bought pretzels at a concession stand. Eli ate the salt off his before touching the bread. He asked whether Matthew had ever been married. Matthew said no. He asked whether Matthew had a dog. Matthew said he used to have a German shepherd named Pepper, who had lived fourteen years and had once eaten an entire birthday cake. Eli looked delighted. "Can we get a dog?"
Matthew almost said yes. Then he remembered that he was still learning how to care for a child, his work shifts were long, and the kinship placement had not changed. "Maybe someday," he answered. "First we need to figure out our schedules and make sure a dog would get the care it needs."
Eli kicked a stone along the path. "You're like Aunt Maria. You always say maybe."
"That's because maybe is sometimes the truth."
The child considered this for a moment. "Mom always said no if she meant no."
"Then I'll try to do the same."
Near the end of the visit, Eli asked if Matthew would still come next week if the boy was angry with him. Matthew turned toward him. "Yes. You can be angry with me. You can tell me you don't like something I did. I may have to explain a rule, and sometimes the rule will stay, but I won't stop showing up because you have feelings."
Eli looked down at the pond. "Ray got mad if I was mad."
"I know he hurt your mother and frightened you. I'm sorry. You shouldn't have had to learn that kind of fear."
"Sometimes I feel mad at Mom too," Eli said, voice barely audible. "She didn't tell me about you."
Matthew felt an immediate urge to defend Sarah. He loved her memory and could not bear the idea of their son blaming her. But his therapist had warned him that children often feel anger toward the people they lost, and shaming the anger only drives it underground. "It's okay to be mad," he said. "I feel that way sometimes too. Then I remember how scared she was. Both things are true."