Jack had been separated from his wife at the time of Sarah's summer at the diner. He remembered long conversations during which he had begun to care for her, but he was certain they had never been intimate. Aaron, newly divorced then, remembered a brief relationship that he had believed was private and kind. Matthew remembered loving Sarah in the unfinished way of adults who had not known how to ask for a shared future. All three understood that paternity tests could settle the biological question, but none knew what would happen to their lives in the meantime.
Aaron looked at Eli across the room. The boy was drinking orange juice beside Margaret and attempting to eat half a sandwich. "Whoever the answer is," Aaron said quietly, "we don't make him feel like the rest of us lose something."
Jack nodded. "We tell him we're here because he needs people, not because we need a verdict."
Matthew had not moved from the window. He was fifty now, broad-shouldered and scarred above one eyebrow, with tattoos he rarely explained to strangers. He worked repairing diesel engines and lived alone in a small house near the river. During military service he had learned how to remain functional under stress; after service he had learned that functioning and healing were not the same thing. He had gone to counseling for nightmares and periods of anger that embarrassed him. He had no children, had once wanted them desperately, and had spent enough years convincing himself that life had chosen otherwise.
When he looked at Eli, he saw the shape of Sarah's eyes and the way the boy tried to sit upright despite exhaustion. He also saw an uncertain future full of mistakes he might make. Fatherhood was not something that arrived with a leather patch and a solemn promise. He knew that. The possibility that he was this boy's father frightened him precisely because it mattered.
"If it's me," he said at last, "I don't have any idea how to do this."
Ben put one hand on his shoulder. "Neither did any of us. We learned."
"You had nine months to prepare."
"I had nine months to worry," Ben corrected. "Preparation came later."
The day might have ended there, with professional arrangements beginning and the bikers learning to tolerate uncertainty, if Frank Haskins had not tried to leave the property without surrendering a copy of the documents he claimed to hold. Olivia asked him to stay long enough to clarify the guardianship claim and his relationship to the homicide investigation. Frank said he was no longer needed and became angry when she requested the identity of the supervisor who had authorized his participation.
Margaret stepped into the room at the worst possible moment. Frank saw her and stopped. "You," he said, with a contempt that made several people turn. "You always turn everything into a crusade."
"Sarah came to me for help," Margaret answered. "I documented what she told me. That's what lawyers are for."
"And you filled her head with fantasies."
"I showed her options. She chose to leave a violent household. There's a difference."