The first supervised visit took place ten days after the clubhouse incident, in a family services room with crayons, a sofa, and a small table. Maria sat nearby reading paperwork, and a family support worker remained available. Jack, Aaron, and Matthew arrived at different times so Eli would not have to manage three unfamiliar men at once. Jack brought a small model motorcycle but asked permission before giving it. Aaron brought a used illustrated book about desert animals because Eli had mentioned liking lizards. Matthew brought nothing, and afterward he was glad.
Eli looked at him for a long time. "You really knew my mom?"
"I did. We were friends. We cared about each other."
"She never said your name."
Matthew nodded. "I wish she had. I wish a lot of things had happened differently. But none of that is because you did anything wrong."
The boy picked at the seam on his sleeve. "If you're my dad, are you going to take me away from Aunt Maria?"
"Nobody gets to make that choice just by wanting it," Matthew said. "The adults responsible for you will work out what is safe. I won't make you choose between people who care about you."
Eli thought about that. "Could you still visit if you're not my dad?"
"If you want me to, and the people caring for you agree, yes."
The child's shoulders eased a fraction. He reached for a crayon and drew a motorcycle with one enormous front wheel. Matthew asked whether the rear wheel was supposed to be that small. Eli informed him that he knew nothing about art. It was the first teasing Matthew had heard from him, and he carried it home with a ridiculous, unreasonable sense of joy.
The DNA testing was arranged through a properly accredited laboratory, with the consent and legal authorization required for a child in temporary state-supervised kinship care. The social worker explained what a biological result could tell them and what it could not. It might identify a father. It would not automatically alter custody, establish a bond, or determine whether somebody was ready to care for a child recovering from severe trauma. Jack and Aaron understood. Matthew said he understood too, though every day of waiting made the distinction harder to live with.
At the second visit Eli asked Jack why his name was Reaper. Jack grinned and said it was an old joke from a charity race where he had worn a black raincoat and frightened his own friends by appearing out of the fog. Ben insisted the real story involved a disastrous Halloween costume and a motorcycle that stalled in front of a cemetery. Both accounts were probably embellished. Eli laughed until he hiccuped, then looked guilty for laughing while his mother was dead.
Maria noticed the change in his face and sat beside him. "You can laugh and miss your mom at the same time," she said. "They don't cancel each other out."
"She used to laugh at me when I made monsters out of pancakes."
"Then we'll make some monsters this weekend."
He took her hand. "Can Matthew come?"
Maria looked across the room at the big man sitting on the carpet with a plastic motorcycle in his lap. "We'll ask the people supervising visits," she said. "And then, if it's okay, we'll invite him."