The ache of losing a place was different from losing a person, but each made the other harder to bear. When Caleb wrote that he had a room ready for her, she was drawn less by the prospect of marriage than by the idea of waking in a place that might remain hers.
Caleb had a history of his own, though he revealed it more slowly. His father had been a carpenter in Ohio who expected his sons to follow the trade, and his mother had worked in a boardinghouse where she learned to make a guest feel welcome without pretending every guest was a friend. Caleb went west at twenty-four seeking wages on the stage road and eventually purchased a struggling station from a man eager to move on. He wrote home regularly, sending photographs that made the buildings look grander than they were and accounts of the frontier that omitted the worst of the weather. His mother visited once after his father died and stayed long enough to teach him how to make bread that did not resemble roofing material.
She had loved Cottonwood despite its inconveniences. She planted the flowers that still returned each summer beside the kitchen window and told Caleb that a house ought to contain something growing for no reason except beauty. He laughed at the idea while she lived there, then watered the flower bed faithfully after her death. When Nora asked about the blossoms on her first evening, he nearly told her everything and stopped because it was hard to confess how much of his life remained arranged around someone who could no longer return. Instead he said the flowers had been his mother's, which was true but not complete.
One afternoon, while Nora was helping Luke sort a heap of tangled harness, the boy asked why Caleb had never married. Nora answered that she did not know and suspected the question was better put to Caleb. Luke looked embarrassed and said that some people in town believed the stationkeeper had been disappointed by a woman years earlier. Nora said people in towns sometimes supplied romances to explain ordinary loneliness. She did not repeat the rumor, though she wondered whether Caleb had offered his letters because he trusted her or because he was tired of having only his own decisions for company.
Luke himself had grown up along the stage road. His father, Daniel Merritt, once repaired wagons for a traveling outfit until a threshing machine injured his hand and made heavy work uncertain. Luke left school earlier than his teacher wanted and took a position with Caleb in exchange for wages, meals, and the chance to learn stable work. He was quick with horses but impatient with figures; he could recognize a lame animal by its gait while forgetting whether a customer had paid two dollars or three. Nora saw that the boy feared arithmetic because he had been told too often that people who worked with their hands did not need it.